Analysis on acupoints selection and combination for functional dyspepsia: Data mining of randomized controlled trials
Yu-qiao CHEN,Jia-li WU,Nai-xuan WEI,Meng-ting QIU,Xiao-mei SHAO,Jiao-qiao FANG,Jun-fan FANG,Jun-ying DU,Zi GUO
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wjam.2023.06.001
2023-06-09
World Journal of Acupuncture - Moxibustion
Abstract:摘要 背景 本研究通过数据挖掘技术总结分析针灸治疗功能性消化不良(FD)的穴位组方规律. 方法 系统检索9个数据库, 基于关联规则挖掘和网络分析, 对FD治疗中的穴位处方进行提取和分析.通过正向推理,反向推理,贝叶斯分析等方法对伴有烦躁症状的FD患者的穴位处方进行深入分析. 结果 共纳入45篇文献, 涉及30个穴位, 总应用频次为172次, 涉及29个经穴和1个奇穴, 分布于10条经脉.使用频率居前三位的穴位分别为足三里(19.77%),内关(16.86%)和中脘(12.21%).穴位涉及经脉最多的是足阳明胃经(34次).最常用的穴位组合为内关和足三里.核心处方为足三里,内关,天枢,中脘.对于伴有烦躁症状的FD患者, 经正向推理, 穴位处方为:内关,太冲,期门,中脘,膻中,天枢,足三里;采用反向推理和贝叶斯分析, 穴位处方为:内关,中脘,膻中,三阴交,天枢,足三里. 结论:足三里 ,内关,天枢,中脘可作为治疗FD患者的主要处方.对于伴有烦躁症状的FD患者, 可同时穴取内关,中脘,膻中,天枢,足三里. Background The aim of the study was to explore the regularity of acupoints combination in the treatment of functional dyspepsia (FD) by means of data mining technology. Methods We conducted a systematic search of nine databases from their inception to December 2022 to identify eligible randomized control trials (RCTs). The acupoints prescriptions in the treatment of FD were extracted and analyzed based on association rule mining and network analysis. Furthermore, the acupoints prescribed for irritability symptom of FD were quantified by forward inference, reverse inference and Bayes factor (BF) correction. Results A total of 45 RCTs on 30 acupoints were included, involving 172 times the total application frequency. Analysis of acupoints prescriptions covered 29 meridian acupoints and one extra-ordinary point, disturbing in 10 meridians. The top three acupoints in application frequency were Zusanli (ST36, 19.77%), Neiguan (PC6, 16.86%), Zhongwan (CV12, 12.21%). The most involved meridian was the foot yangming stomach meridian (34 times). The most frequently used acupoints combinations were PC6 and ST36. The core prescriptions were ST36, PC6, Tianshu(ST25), CV12. The specificities of acupoints selection for FD with dysphoria as follows: using the forward inference, PC6, Taichong(LR3), Qimen(LR14), CV12, Danzhong(CV17), ST25, ST36 were selected. Using the reverse inference and BF correction, PC6, CV12, CV17, Sanyinjiao(SP6), ST25, ST36 were selected. Conclusion ST36, PC6, ST25, CV12 could be used as the main prescriptions in treating FD. For FD with dysphoria the acupoints prescription is PC6, CV12, CV17, ST25 and ST36.
integrative & complementary medicine