Comparison of Percutaneous Neprolithotomy and Flexible Ureteroscopy for Solitary Renal Pelvis Calculi and the Impacts on Renal Function

刘斌,董杰,周水根,田丰,张征宇,高建平,王龙信
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1009-6604.2014.05.014
2014-01-01
Abstract:Objective To compare the clinical effect of percutaneous neprolithotomy ( PCNL ) and flexible ureteroscopy Holmium laser lithotripsy in the treatment of solitary renal pelvis calculi and the impacts on renal function . Methods From July 2011 to June 2013, 58 cases of solitary renal pelvis calculi were treated by holmium laser lithotripsy in our department , of which 30 cases were treated with PCNL ( PCNL group ) , and 28 cases with electronic flexible ureteroscopy ( Flexible ureteroscopy group ) respectively.The operative time, blood loss, stone clearance rate of the two groups were compared .Moreover, blood samples of the two groups were analyzed for blood urea nitrogen ( BUN ) , creatinine ( Cr ) , neutrophils gelatinase-associated lipocalin ( NGAL ) concentration 24 h before operation and 3, 24, 48 h after operation, respectively. Results There was no statistical difference in stone clearance rate [76.2%(PCNL group) vs.75.6%(Flexible ureteroscopy group), χ2 =0.022, P=0.882].The mean blood loss in Flexible ureteroscopy group was (50.3 ±21.5) ml, which was less than that of PCNL group (80.2 ±20.5) ml (t=5.422, P=0.000), while the operative time was longer than that of PCNL group [(60.5 ±25.1) min vs.(45.3 ±10.5) min, t=-3.045, P=0.004].The serum NGAL in the two groups significantly increased 3 h after operation [PCNL group: (3.8 ±0.7)μg/L vs. (6.3 ±0.5)μg/L, q=22.068,P<0.05;Flexible ureteroscopy group:(3.6 ±0.6)μg/L vs.(7.9 ±0.8)μg/L, q=33.457, P<0.05], with that of Flexible ureteroscopy group being higher than that of the PCNL group [(7.9 ±0.8)μg/L vs.(6.3 ±0.5)μg/L, t=-9.200,P=0.000].The serum NGAL in the two groups began to decrease 24 h after operation but didn’t reach its preoperative level 48 h after operation(q=4.414,P<0.05;q=8.559,P<0.05).The levels of Cr and BUN in two groups did not show significant changes between preoperation and postoperation (P>0.05). Conclusion PCNL and flexible ureteroscopy are effective in the treatment of solitary renal pelvis calculi , and both could cause reversible damage on renal function .
What problem does this paper attempt to address?