Reliability analysis of different imaging modalities for measuring clivus-canal angle

Chang-qing ZHAO,Yu-jian DING,Kai ZHANG,Wei SUN,Hua LI,Jie ZHAO
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1672-2957.2014.04.008
2014-01-01
Journal of Spinal Surgery
Abstract:Objective To compare the intra-observer and inter-observer reliability of X-ray film and CT saggital recon-struction imaging modalities for measuring clivus-canal angle in different patients , and to discuss its clinical relevance for occipitocervical fusion.Methods A totle of 189 orthopedic patients without symptoms related to upper cervical spinal cord compression ( NC group) and 37 patients with malalignment of occipito-atlanto-axial complex and symptoms related to upper cervical spinal cord compression ( MC group) were included in the study .The clivus-canal angle was measured on lateral cer-vical radiographs of neutral and extension-flexion position .Two observers independently measured clivus-canal angle of 10 pa-tients from NC group and 10 patients from MC group using X-ray film and CT saggital reconstruction methods on 2 separate oc-casions , and the intra-observer and inter-observer reliability of the 2 imaging modalities were analyzed .Results The values of clivus-canal angle measured on flexion , neutral and extension position in NC group were significantly higher than that in MC group (P<0.01) respectively.The range of the value change of clivus-canal angle in NC group was 23.87°±10.23°, also significantly higher than that in MC group , which was 19.10°±7.96°(P<0.01).The occipito-atlanto-axial complex of the patients in MC group was more rigid and flexed than in NC group .The inter-observer correlation coefficient for X-ray films and CT saggital reconstruction were 0.619 and 0.897, respectively.The intra-observer correlation coefficient among observer 1 and observer 2 for X-ray films were 0.635 and 0.657, while that for CT saggital reconstruction were 0.937 and 0.924.CT saggital reconstruction could improve the reliability of measuring clivus-canal angle in comparison to X-ray method.Conclu-sion The current study gave the value range of clivus-canal angle in different patient populations , and provided practical evi-dence for patient positioning and determination of fixed angle of occipito -atlanto-axial complex during occipitocervical fusion procedure.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?