Comparison of short wave and laser therapy in the treatment of knee osteoarthritis

Cong-cong LI,Yan-ping ZHAI,Yuan-yuan LUO,Cheng XIE,Bing-chen AN,Jie-jiao ZHENG
2018-01-01
Abstract:Objective:To compare the efficacy of short-wave therapy and laser therapy in the treatment of knee osteoarthritis (KOA) and to optimize the treatment plan of physical therapy during the onset of KOA.Methods:Forty-eight cases of KOA were randomly divided into short-wave group and laser group,24 cases in each group,treated with Voltaren 75 mg once a day,and the range of motion training of whole joint and quadricep exercise were carried;laser therapy group was treated with laser therapy while the short-wave group was treated with short-wave.The pain,stiffness,and physical function changes of the WOMAC score were compared between 15 treatments.Results:From baseline to 15 treatments,the short-wave therapy group demonstrated improvement in WOMAC pain (10.58±3.98 vs 3.54±2.15,P<0.05),stiffness(3.17±l.69 vs 1.17±0.87,P<0.05),and physical function score(33.54±l 2.96 vs 20.67±11.98,P<0.05).The laser therapy group demonstrated improvement in WOMAC pain (10.50±3.53 vs 7.04±2.14,P<0.05),and physical function score (29.38±11.93 vs21.29±7.89,P<0.05).No significant improvement in stiffness (2.79±1.96 vs 1.92±1.44,P> 0.05)was observed.In addition,after the treatment,short-wave group vs laser group,the pain score in the WOMAC were 7.04±2.82 vs 3.46±2.70 (P<0.05),stiffness score were 2.00±1.38 vs 0.88±0.99(P<0.05).Conclusion:Short-wave therapy can alleviate the pain and improve the stiffness and is better than laser therapy,due to the deep penetration depth of short-wave,suggesting that the subchondral bone disease is one of most important pathological mechanism of KOA.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?