Abstract:Additive-subtractive hybrid manufacturing (ASHM) holds great potential for producing lightweight and ready-to-use parts with high accuracy within a single workstation. It is viewed as a promising technology to improve material efficiency and shorten manufacturing cycle. However, the energy-efficient manufacturing is not always achieved due to the huge electrical energy consumption in the manufacturing phase. It is not a simple “yes-or-no” question that ASHM process is more energy-saving than conventional subtractive manufacturing (CSM) process for production of a given part when considering the life cycle energy demand. For addressing this problem, this paper developed a decision-making model for quantitatively analyzing and comparing the energy demand of ASHM process and CSM process. The model takes into account the whole life cycle of the part, including pre-manufacturing phase, manufacturing phase, use phase, and end-of-life recycling. The critical variables of solid-to-envelope ratio, lightweight ratio, energy consumption reduction coefficient (ERC) are embedded in the model, and their synergistic effects on energy demand comparison are comprehensively analyzed. Moreover, the electrical specific energy consumption of the manufacturing phase was extrapolated as a function of the process parameters in the two manufacturing processes, and the unique relationship between specific energy consumption and process rate, laser power of the ASHM process is established, which can improve the generality of the decision-making model. The results indicated that parts used in aerospace are more suitable for production with ASHM process due to the lightweight and extremely high ERC, which leads to less energy consumption in the use phase compared to conventional manufactured parts. In static non-moving usage scenario, when the material recycling process is not considered, the manufacturing phase in ASHM process accounts for a large amount of total energy consumption, reached about 84%, while the material production in CSM process accounts for the largest proportion, reached almost 86%. In addition, process rate in ASHM process has an important effect on the electrical energy consumption in the manufacturing phase. By increasing the process rate from 1.5 to 5.5 g/min, the energy consumption of the manufacturing phase in ASHM process was saved by 38%. This work provides a quantitative method for decision-makers to select the sustainable manufacturing process when producing a functional part.

A Comparative Life Cycle Assessment of a Selective-Laser-melting-produced Hydraulic Valve Body Using Design for Property

Life cycle assessment of selective-laser-melting-produced hydraulic valve body with integrated design and manufacturing optimization: A cradle-to-gate study

Localized Property Design and Gradient Processing of a Hydraulic Valve Body Using Selective Laser Melting

Friction and Lubrication Behavior of a Selective Laser Melted Hydraulic Spool Valve under Contaminated Conditions

Structural optimization of hydraulic valve block based on generative design and selective laser melting process simulation

Structure Optimization for Passages in Hydraulic Manifolds Using Metal Additive Manufacturing Technology

Critical Life Cycle Inventory for Aluminum Die Casting: A Lightweight-Vehicle Manufacturing Enabling Technology

Environmental life cycle assessment of an automobile component fabricated by additive and conventional manufacturing

A LCA and LCC analysis of pure subtractive manufacturing, wire arc additive manufacturing, and selective laser melting approaches

Comparative sustainability assessment of powder bed fusion and solid-state additive manufacturing processes: The case of direct metal laser sintering versus additive friction stir deposition

A Comparative Study of Metal Additive Manufacturing Processes for Elevated Sustainability

Comparative Life Cycle Assessment of SLS and mFFF Additive Manufacturing Techniques for the Production of a Metal Specimen

Multi-Objective Optimization of Selective Laser Melting Processes for Minimizing Energy Consumption and Maximizing Product Tensile Strength

Life cycle assessment of lattice structures: Balancing mass saving and productivity

Life cycle assessment of additive manufacturing processes: A review

Low-carbon design of structural components by integrating material and structural optimization

A decision-making model for comparing the energy demand of additive-subtractive hybrid manufacturing and conventional subtractive manufacturing based on life cycle method

Environmental aspects of laser-based and conventional tool and die manufacturing

Additive manufacturing for the automotive industry: on the life-cycle environmental implications of material substitution and lightweighting through re-design

Comparative environmental impact assessment of additive-subtractive manufacturing processes for Inconel 625: A life cycle analysis

Research on the optimal design and manufacture of TC4 titanium alloy structural parts with selective laser melting technology