Abstract:When a subsurface flaw is located near the component free surface, the first step consists of characterizing the flaw as surface or subsurface in compliance with subsurface-to-surface flaw proximity rules. The re-characterization process from subsurface to surface flaw is addressed in all Fitness-for-Service (FFS) Codes. However, the specific criteria for the rules on transforming subsurface flaws to surface flaws are different among the FFS Codes. This re-characterization concept is essential and important for subsurface flaws in the flaw assessment procedures. It is applied for three stages of the flaw assessment: at service inspection for flaw characterization, at subcritical crack growth calculation, such as fatigue crack growth, and at ductile/brittle fracture assessment. In this frame, fatigue crack growth experiments were recently conducted by the authors and it was highlighted that the subsurface-to-surface transformation is highly sensitive to the aspect ratio a/l of the flaw whereas the proximity factors in the rules are defined by constant values i.e., regardless of the flaw aspect ratios a/l. The authors have therefore proposed a new subsurface-to-surface flaw proximity rule based on experimental data and equivalent fatigue crack growth rates. Then, the authors demonstrated through numerous Fatigue Crack Growth (FCG) calculations that the current ASME B&PV Code Section XI surface proximity factor should be updated according to the type of component i.e., piping or vessel. The paper summarizes all the steps leading to the improvement of the ASME Code Section XI subsurface-to-surface proximity rule, from the fatigue crack growth experiments to the studies of the suitability of the current flaw-to-surface proximity factor. Furthermore, based on additional fatigue crack growth calculations and more refined investigations, the paper proposes finally a new limit value for the surface proximity factor. As a result, a proposal for modification of the ASME Code Section XI, Appendix C is provided. The paper is used for the technical basis of this proposal.

Evaluation of Stress Intensity Factor Interactions Between Adjacent Flaws with Large Aspect Ratios

Characterization of Interaction Between Elliptical Subsurface Flaws

Stress Intensity Factors for Transformed Surface Flaws and Remaining Fatigue Lives Based on Flaw-to-Surface Proximity Rules

Rules For Flaw Interaction For Subsurface Flaws In Operating Pressurized Vessels: Technical Basis Of Code Case N-877

Fatigue Lives of Multiple Flaws in Accordance with Combination Rule

Study on the Relationship Between Interaction Factors and Stress Intensity Factor for Elliptical Flaws

INTRODUCTION OF SUBSURFACE PROXIMITY CRITERIA IN THE WORLD AND STRESS INTENSITY FACTORS FOR TRANSFORMED SURFACE FLAWS

Fatigue Crack Growth Calculations for Vessels Considering Subsurface to Surface Flaw Proximity Rules

Alternative Characterization Rules for Multiple Surface Planar Flaws

Development of Stress Intensity Factors for Subsurface Flaws in Plates Subjected to Polynomial Stress Distributions

Plastic Collapse Stresses Based on Flaw Combination Rules for Pipes Containing Two Circumferential Similar Flaws

Study on Flaw-to-Surface Proximity Rule for Transforming Subsurface Flaws to Surface Flaws Based on Fatigue Crack Growth Experiments

Proposal of a New Subsurface-to-Surface Flaw Transformation Rule for Fatigue Crack Growth Analyses

Flaw-to-surface proximity rules and fatigue crack growth behavior for transformed surface flaws

Re-Characterization of Subsurface Flaw to Surface Flaw Based on Equivalent Fatigue Crack Growth Rate

Effect of the Thickness on Re-Characterisation of Subsurface to Surface Flaw: Application on Piping and Vessels

Theoretical Analysis of Stress Intensity Factors and Interactions of Collinear Flaws with Unequal Lengths in Brittle Solids Under Uniaxial Tensile Conditions

Plastic Collapse Stresses for Pipes With Circumferential Twin Flaws Using Combination Rules

Study on Flaw Acceptance Standard of ASME Code Sec. XI Based on Failure Probability

Fatigue Crack Growth for Subsurface Flaws Near Component Surface and Proximity Rules

Proximity Factor on Transformation from Subsurface to Surface Flaw