Arthroscopic Meniscectomy and Suture Repair for Bucket-Handle Meniscus Tears

杨睿,李卫平,沈慧勇,宋斌,黄建荣,张正政,宋洋,唐勇,黄霖,梁新军,王鹏

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.issn.1671-7600.2010.04.007

2010-01-01

Abstract:Objective To compare the therapeutic effects between arthroscopic suture repair and arthroscopic sub-total or total meniscectomy for bucket-handle meniscus tears.Methods Thirty-four patients(34 knees)with bucket-handle meniscus tear were treated in our hospital from January 2005 to January 2009.Fifteen patients(Group A)received arthroscopic meniscus suture repair(all-inside or all-inside combined with outside-in).During the same period 19 patients(Group B)sustained total or subtotal meniscectomy.Groups A and B were compared in terms of symptoms,physical signs,range of motion(ROM)of the knee joint,and the Lysholm scores.There were no significant differences in ROM,Lysholm scores,age and sex distribution before surgery.Results All patients in the 2 groups had been followed up for an arerage of 17.2 months(12 to 24 months).Between groups A and B,there were no significant differences in ROM after surgery or in Lysholm scores 6 months after operation,but there were significant differences in Lysholm scores 12 months after surgery.Group A was superior to group B.Conclusions For large meniscal tears like bucket-handle ones,arthroscopic suture technique provides stable strength repair along the whole length of injured region and consequently achieves satisfactory clinical outcomes.It should be recommended as a conventional therapeutic method.