The influence of partial volume effect on the measurement of lesion to background ratio in standard SPECT and coincidence circuit SPECT: a phantom study

李河北,王茜,王玉,秦淑玲,赵亚妹,张彩群
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.issn.2095-2848.2008.06.015
2008-01-01
Abstract:Objective Partial volume effect is known to cause incorrect estimation of radiopharma-ceutical uptake. The aim of this study was to evaluate the influence of partial volume effect on the measure-ment of lesion to background ratio (L/B) in standard SPECT and coincidence circuit SPECT. Methods Using a simplified Jaszczak phantom containing 6 cylinders to simulate lesions with diameters of 2.8, 1.8,1.3, 0.8, 0.8 and 0.8 cm, standard SPECT with 999TcmO4- and coincidence SPECT with 18F-fluorodeox-yglucese (FDG) studies were performed. The average background counts and three types of L/B values were measured, namely L/B1 for maximal counts ratio; L/B2 for the average counts ratio with the size of re-gion of interest (ROI) equal to the lesion; and L/B3 for the average counts ratio of 6 pixels size in ROI.The L/B ratios were compared with the contrasts. SPSS 11.0 was used to calculate Paired Student's t test, linear correlation and regression. Results When the contrast was set to 2:1 in standard SPECT and 2:1 or 2.5:1 in coincidence SPECT, the lesions with 0.8 cm in diameter could not be detected. Except for the le-sion with 2.8 cm in diameter in coincidence SPECT, the L/B values were all significantly underestimated and there was strong positive correlation between the L/B values and the contrasts. The smaller the lesion size, the greater was the underestimation of the L/B values. The regression equations were Y2.8=0.086+0.689 Xcontrast, Y1.8=0.350+0.436 Xcontrast, Y103=0.837+0.307 Xcontrast Y0.8=0.564 + 0.199 Xcontrast for standard SPECT series, and Y2.8=0.221+0.941 X Y1.8=0.426 +0.647 XcontrastY1.3=0.484 +0.528 Xcontrast Y0.8=0.429+0.318 Xcontrast for coincidence SPECT series. The L/B values using the maxi-mum lesion radioactivity counts had the best results. Conclusions Significant partial volume effects on L/B ratios were detected in SPECT and coincidence SPECT, particularly the former. Calibration by regression equa-tion using the maximum L/B value may yield the best correction parameters.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?