Chrome incorporation in high-pressure Fe–Mg oxides
Alan B. Woodland,Katrin Schumann,Laura Uenver-Thiele,Kevin Rosbach,Tiziana Boffa Ballaran,Caterina Melai,Elena Bykova
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5194/ejm-36-845-2024
2024-09-19
European Journal of Mineralogy
Abstract:Abstract. The occurrence of Cr-bearing oxide phases as inclusions in diamonds and in extraterrestrial materials has the potential to serve as an indicator of formation conditions. However, such an application requires detailed knowledge of phase stabilities and the influence that Cr may have on its stability. To this end, the incorporation of Cr in high-pressure post-spinel Fe–Mg oxide phases was experimentally investigated at pressures of 14–22 GPa and temperatures between 1100 and 1600 °C using a multi-anvil press. We find that neither the Fe3Cr2O6 nor the Mg3Cr2O6 endmember composition is stable over the expected range of pressure and temperature where Fe5O6 itself is known to be stable. Further experiments along the Fe32+Fe23+O6–Fe32+Cr2O6 binary indicate only small amounts of Cr substitution are possible: ∼ 0.12 cations Cr per formula unit or ∼ 6 mol % Fe32+Cr2O6 component. In contrast, complete solid solution is apparent across both the Fe22+(Cr,Fe3+)2O5 and the Mg2(Cr,Fe3+)2O5 binaries, and there are indications of complete solution in the entire (Mg,Fe2+)2(Cr,Fe3+)2O5 quaternary system. The O5-structured phase usually coexists with (Fe,Mg)O. At 16–20 GPa, a post-spinel phase with O4 stoichiometry was occasionally encountered, having either a modified Ca-ferrite- (mCF-FeCr2O4) or a Ca-titanate-type (CT-MgCr2O4) structure. In one high-temperature experiment at 1600 °C, an unquenchable Mg-rich phase with a reconstructed Mg4Fe23+O7 stoichiometry occurred together with Mg2(Cr,Fe3+)2O5. In one experiment at 1100 °C and 16 GPa with a bulk composition of Mg2(Cr0.6,Fe0.43+)2O5, an assemblage of O5 phase + eskolaite–hematite solid solution + periclase was obtained together with minor amounts of the CT-type phase and a β-(Cr,Fe)OOH phase. The occurrence of these two minor phases in this low-temperature experiment is an indicator of variable reaction kinetics amongst the starting materials, which caused chemical heterogeneities to develop at the onset of the experiment. The structural systematics of Fe22+(Cr,Fe3+)2O5 and (Fe2+,Mg)2(Cr,Fe3+)2O5 solid solutions were investigated. It is notable that the Fe3+ and Cr endmembers have somewhat different crystal structures, belonging to space groups Cmcm (no. 63) and Pbam (no. 55), respectively. The phase transition occurs around the midpoint of the Fe3+–Cr joins. In spite of complexities in the behavior of the unit-cell parameters, the variation in molar volume with composition deviates only slightly from linearity. Wüstite and periclase coexisting in our experiments reveal the incorporation of up to 9 wt % and 25 wt % Cr2O3, respectively. This is consistent with the minor Cr contents reported for some ferropericlase inclusions in natural diamond. The limited solubility of other cations in Fe5O6 limits the likelihood of it being an accessory phase in the Earth's deep upper mantle and transition zone, except in Fe-rich environments. In contrast, the O5 phase appears to be more flexible in accommodating a range of divalent and trivalent cations, suggesting that this phase is more likely to be stabilized, potentially where redox reactions related to diamond formation occur.
mineralogy