Abstract:This paper describes a fundamental and empirically conspicuous problem inherent to surveys of human feelings and opinions in which subjective responses are elicited on numerical scales. The paper also proposes a solution. The problem is a tendency by some individuals — particularly those with low levels of education — to simplify the response scale by considering only a subset of possible responses such as the lowest, middle, and highest. In principle, this "focal value rounding" (FVR) behavior renders invalid even the weak ordinality assumption often used in analysis of such data. With "happiness" or life satisfaction data as an example, descriptive methods and a multinomial logit model both show that the effect is large and that education and, to a lesser extent, income level are predictors of FVR behavior. A model simultaneously accounting for the underlying wellbeing and for the degree of FVR is able to estimate the latent subjective wellbeing, i.e. the counterfactual full-scale responses for all respondents, the biases associated with traditional estimates, and the fraction of respondents who exhibit FVR. Addressing this problem helps to resolve a longstanding puzzle in the life satisfaction literature, namely that the returns to education, after adjusting for income, appear to be small or negative. Due to the same econometric problem, the marginal utility of income in a subjective wellbeing sense has been consistently underestimated.

The Returns to Education: Microeconomics

Factors Influencing the Return on Household Education Investment: Empirical Evidence from China

Improving the Accuracy of Estimated Returns to Education in China- Based on Employment Rate, Career Length, and Income Growth

Returns to Education: The Causal Effects of Education on Earnings, Health, and Smoking

Returns to investment in education: a decennial review of the global literature

Like Father Like Son? Revisiting the Role of Parental Education in Estimating Returns to Education in China

The return to higher education: evidence from Romania

Returns to endogenous education: the case of Honduras

Heterogeneity, Self-Selection Bias and Return to Education

Social and Economic Returns to College Education in the United States

Economic Returns to Higher Education: Signaling V. Human Capital Theory

The Importance of Cognitive Domains and the Returns to Schooling in South Africa: Evidence from Two Labor Surveys

The Nonmarket Benefits of Education and Ability

The Returns of a Community College Education: Evidence From the National Education Longitudinal Survey

The econometrics of happiness: Are we underestimating the returns to education and income?

Returns to College Education Reexamined: Individual Treatment Effects, Selection Bias, and Sorting Gain

The Returns to Education in Thailand: A Pseudo-Panel Approach

Sequential Choices, Option Values, and the Returns to Education

Returns to Education, Productivity, and Economic Growth in China

The Returns to Education in Rural China: Some New Estimates