Abstract:Using detailed Norwegian data on earnings, education and work histories, we estimate a dynamic structural model of education and sector choices that captures rich life-cycle patterns by ability. We validate the model against variation in education choices induced by a compulsory schooling reform. Our approach allows us to estimate the ex-ante returns to different education tracks across the life-cycle by individual ability and quantify the contribution of option values. We find substantial heterogeneity in returns and establish crucial roles for option values and re-enrollment in determining education choices and the impact of schooling policies.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to address two key issues in educational choice: the sequential nature of educational choices and the uncertainty involved. Specifically:
1. **Sequential Nature of Educational Choices**: Traditional educational investment models (such as the Becker and Mincer models) assume that individuals compare future income streams at the beginning of their educational careers and choose the alternative with the highest net return, then complete their desired level of education. However, this view overlooks the sequential nature of educational investments and the uncertainty in the decision-making process. For example, attending an additional year of school may open up more educational opportunities, and individuals often face high uncertainty in costs and benefits during such important decisions.
2. **Uncertainty and Nonlinear Characteristics in Educational Decisions**: The paper develops and estimates a dynamic structural model to explain phenomena such as interruptions, re-enrollments, and track switching in educational histories, as well as the impact of compulsory education policies on choices beyond the minimum educational requirements. This model can generate rich educational and work histories, including interruptions and re-enrollments in educational careers, the persistence of choices across the life cycle, and the switching costs between educational tracks.
Through this model, the paper defines and quantifies two key objects: **ex-ante return** and **option value**. Ex-ante return considers the sequential nature and uncertainty of educational choices, including not only immediate wages and non-monetary rewards but also the discounted lifetime returns of the best alternative compared to the chosen option. Option value arises from the sequential nature of educational decisions, such as the option to enter university after completing a high school diploma, and the option to obtain a university degree upon university admission. These objects are crucial for understanding educational decisions and their impact on policy reforms. Additionally, the paper validates the model's effectiveness using Norwegian administrative data and analyzes the heterogeneity of ex-ante returns and option values for individuals with different abilities and educational tracks. Finally, the paper explores the mechanisms through which compulsory education reforms influence educational choices.