Abstract:Over the last several decades, there has been an arms race to acquire credentials as higher education has shifted from an elitist system to mass education. From an individual perspective, given the higher education system and labor market conditions, it is rational to pursue advanced qualifications. However, whether the education system delivers improvements in human capital or is principally a signaling mechanism is questionable. Estimates of the proportion of labor market rewards due to signaling range as high as 80%, suggesting that education is not only expensive but inefficient. In an increasingly transactional environment in which education providers are highly motivated by financial considerations, this situation is only likely to be exacerbated by the rapid developments in artificial intelligence (AI). The use of AI has the potential to make learning more effective, but given that many students see credential acquisition as transactional, it may reduce both human capital and the value of the signaling effect. If the credibility of the credentials offered is further damaged, the higher education sector in its present form and scale may well be unsustainable. We examine the evidence on credential inflation, returns to education, and mismatch of graduates to jobs before analyzing how AI is likely to affect these trends. We then suggest possible responses of prospective students, education providers, and employers to the growing adoption of AI in both education and the workplace. We conclude that the current offerings of generalist degrees, as opposed to vocational qualifications, are not sustainable and that to survive, even in a downsized form, the sector must respond to this disruptive technology by changing both the nature of its offerings and its methods of ensuring that the credentials they offer reflect genuine student learning.

Economic Returns to Higher Education: Signaling V. Human Capital Theory

Changes in Economic Return to Schooling and Employment Rate with the Expansion of Higher Education

The Returns to Education: Microeconomics

Improving the Accuracy of Estimated Returns to Education in China- Based on Employment Rate, Career Length, and Income Growth

Signaling and Employer Learning with Instruments

Social and Economic Returns to College Education in the United States

Returns to Education: The Causal Effects of Education on Earnings, Health, and Smoking

Research on Signalling of Service Providers Based on Specific Human Capital

Over-education and the Signaling Function of Education

Artificial Intelligence and the Sustainability of the Signaling and Human Capital Roles of Higher Education

The Nonmarket Benefits of Education and Ability

The Returns of a Community College Education: Evidence From the National Education Longitudinal Survey

Journal of the History of Economic Thought Preprints - Economic Analysis of Education in Post-War America: New insights from Theodore Schultz and John Kenneth Galbraith

Signalling to Experts

The undergraduate self-perception of employability: human capital, careers advice, and career ownership

Rethinking the role of human Capital in Growth Models

The Big Sort: College Reputation and Labor Market Outcomes

Do students take the predictions of human capital theory into account? An analysis of motives behind further studies in higher education

The Labor Market Value of Higher Education: Now and in the Future

The Returns to Elite College Education: A Quasi-Experimental Analysis

Signals, Information, and the Value of College Names