Inferring locomotor behavior in Paleogene mammals via eigenshape analysis
k d rose,n macleod
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2475/ajs.293.A.300
1993-01-01
American Journal of Science
Abstract:The inference of locomotor mode in Paleogene mammalian faunas has been traditionally based on qualitative comparisons between fossil postcranial skeletal elements and those of modern forms whose range of locomotor behavior is known. Recently, Van Valkenburgh (1987) has shown that detailed functional interpretations can also be obtained using a series of geometric indices to assess shape correspondences between Oligocene carnivores and a predominantly carnivorous assemblage of modern mammalian species. We generalize and extend Van Valkenburgh's morphometric approach by focusing on an analysis of ungual phalanx and proximal radial head outlines via the eigenshape technique. Results of ungual phalanx analyses show that geometric consideration of the lateral outline is, for the most part, sufficient to discriminate among modern arboreal/scansorial, fossorial, and cursorial species. Phalanx geometries that form the basis for this discrimination can be modelled graphically by the eigenshape approach and involve a wide range of variational modes (for example, dorsoventral depth of the proximal phalanx shaft, curvature of the ventral margin, degree of both mediolateral and dorsoventral compression, relative differentiation of the extensor tubercle). These aspects of ungual phalanx lateral shape variation appear to reflect differences in relative degrees of phalangeal robustness along with both the precision and strength of phalangeal movement. A separate analysis of modern mammal phalanx shape in dorsal view failed to reveal a similar degree of variation among the various locomotor guilds. While this result might be related to the taxonomic composition of our sample (which contained few modern ungulates), the observed phalanx dorsal shape conservatism among non-ungulate taxa does appear to cut across both taxonomic and adaptive classifications. Outline analyses of modern mammal proximal radial heads indicate that this skeletal element can ordinate taxa on the basis of relative ability to supinate the forearm. Separations among the various locomotor guilds are also present within this radial head shape s ace, particularly distinctions between arboreal/scansorial and fossorial/cursorial taxa. Our results also show that when modern mammalian taxa are grouped by geometric correspondences among ungual phalanx and proximal radial head outlines, the consequent associations of taxa are invariably polyphyletic, indicating widespread evolutionary convergence on a relatively small number of characteristic shapes. The predominance of a functional, rather than strictly phylogenetic, signal in our data strongly suggests that the quantitative comparison of fossial ungual phalanx and proximal radial head morphologies with those of modern mammals may lead to improved insight into the probable range of locomotor modes exhibited by fossil mammals. In order to test the feasibility of using an outline-based morphometric approach for the inference of locomotor behavior in fossil mammals, ungual phalanx and proximal radial head outlines from a suite of Paleogene taxa were projected into the set of empirically-defined modern mammal shape spaces, thereby allowing these morphologies to be more completely (in a geometric sense) compared with those of modern morphological analogues. Our results indicate that Arctocyonides, Cantius, Chriacus, Kopidodon, Nannodectes, Plesiadapis, Thyptacodon, and Vulpavus lateral ungual phalanx and/or radial head outlines are similar to those of modern arboreal/scansorial mammals; Hyracotherium, Pachyaena gracilis, and Phenacodus all appear to be morphologically similar to modern cursorial forms; while both Alocodontulum and Palaenodon exhibit strong shape correspondences with modern fossorial taxa. In each case, these inferences as to probable locomotor behavior are consistent with independent functional interpretations based on qualitative analyses of other skeletal character complexes.