Concept-Semantics and A Resolution of Frege's Puzzle
Beihai Zhou
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1674-3202.2010.04.004
2010-01-01
Abstract:Frege's discussion of the Principle of Identity Substitution(PIS) led him to his theory of sense and reference,where Frege's puzzle was introduced.According to the main criticisms of Frege's theory,the puzzle is rooted in the philosophical position based on the direct reference theory.Therefore we may say that this is a puzzle for the direct reference theory.However,Frege's theory is indeed insufficient to resolve this puzzle. Most importantly,Frege's theory only talks about sense and reference,namely only the language layer,lacking a theory of the cognitive layer.This makes it hard to solve the problem of PIS on a theoretical basis.Since Frege's puzzle was introduced by PIS,a satisfactory solution to the puzzle asks for a treatment of the failure of this principle on the logical layer.In the possible-worlds semantics,PIS can take several different forms:A(?)a=b→K_a(a=b),B.M(?)a=b(?)M(?)K_a(a=b),and C. (?)a=b(?)K_a(a=b).The possible-worlds semantics can explain the failure of A but not the failures of B and C.Although the origin of the puzzle was due to PIS, the solution to the puzzle should not only focus on this principle.In this paper,a new solution to Frege's puzzle is given:based on Frege's theory of sense and reference,by adding a concept theory and focusing on the formalization of concept,intension and sense,a new semantics,namely concept-semantics,is established,in which we can talk about the puzzle on these different layers. Concept-semantics has a two-layer structure:the underlying layer is the structure of sense-semantics based on the public meaning of the language in use;on this basis,by adding individual cognitive aspects,we can characterize knowledge and obtain the structure of concept-semantics.Sense-semantics focuses on the relationship between sense and reference while concept-semantics is used to resolve Frege's puzzle on the cognitive and logical aspects.This two-layer structure reflects,in formal semantics,the extension of Frege's original theory to a theory of concepts.The interaction between the language layer and the cognitive layer involved in the puzzle is the key to such a formal semantics. The invalidity of PIS in logic should be a natural consequence of suitable characterizations of concept,intension,and sense.In this light,concept-semantics uniformly solves Frege's puzzle on the different layers.