Analysis of the value of the aberrometer as a basic method for subjective refraction

QU Xiaomei,WANG Lin,ZHOU Xingtao,瞿小妹,汪琳,周行涛,戴锦晖
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3760/CMA.J.ISSN.1008-1801.2007.06.006
2007-01-01
Abstract:Objective To compare the results of refractive error measurements obtained with a WFA-1000 aberrometer and autorefractor and subjective refraction with a phoropter; to check the accuracy of measuring refractive errors with an aberrometer. Methods Two hundred fifty-two eyes of 129 myopia patients were divided into 3 groups based on refractive error: moderate myopia group (<-6.0 D), high myopia group (-6.0~9.0 D) and hypermyopia group (>9.0 D). Aberrometer measurement, autorefraction and subjective refraction with a phoropter were performed. The degree of spherical error and astigmatism and the axis of astigmatism were recorded and analyzed by statistical software (SAS). Results ①Moderate myopia group:the respective spherical values measured with subjective refraction,autorefraction and an aberrometer were (-3.28±2.52)D,(-3.18±2.93)D and (-2.86±2.89)D while astigmatism values were (-1.24±1.86)D, (-1.99±1.56)D and (-1.35±1.28)D, and the axes of astigmatism were 81.68±73.26,70.11±58.99 and 89.14±78.90. There were no statistically significant differences when these three methods were compared (P>0.05). ②High myopia group:the respective spherical values measured with subjective refraction, autorefraction and an aberrometer were (-7.43±1.27)D, (-7.38±1.03)D and (-7.81±1.19)D, while astigmatism values were (-1.16±1.02)D, (-1.12±0.75)D and (-1.41±1.64)D, and the axes of astigmatism were 86.50±71.24, 94.71±65.03 and 100.62±74.07. There were no statistically significant differences when these three methods were compared (P>0.05). ③Hypermyopia group:the respective spherical values measured with subjective refraction, autorefraction and an aberrometer were (-14.07±4.09)D, (-12.12±3.66)D and (-11.75±3.19)D, while astigmatism values were (-2.02±1.59)D, (-0.74±0.71)D and (-1.05±0.77)D, and the axes of astigmatism were 86.27±63.87, 77.68±57.85 and 110.36±70.83. There were no statistically significant differences in the measurements of the spherical error and the axis of astigmatism when the three methods were compared (P>0.05). But there were statistically significant differences in the degree of astigmatism measured by these three methods (P<0.05). Conclusion An aberrometer in clinical use can accurately measure the refraction of most myopes but it is not appropriate for hypermyopia patients.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?