Vocal characteristics of speech disorder and efficacy of speech therapy in postoperative patients with cleft palate
Qiu Wei-hong,Hao Yuan-tao,Wan Gui-fang,XiQuan Hu,Wen Hong-mei,Zulin Dou
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3321/j.issn:1673-8225.2006.44.012
2006-01-01
Abstract:AIM:To study the clinical characteristics of speech disorder and the efficacy of speech therapy on the postoperative patient with cleft palate.METHODS:A total of 16 postoperative cleft palate patients with speech disorder were selected from the Outpatients Department of Rehabilitation Medicine,the Third Affiliated Hospital of Sun Yat-sen University from June 2003 to October 2005.They were assessed with dysarthria method from China Rehabilitation Research Center,and speech articulation was evaluated with Chinese Character Scale for Articulation Test edited by Wang Guo-min.Taking /te/,/pai/,/kan/and /si/as phone samples,spectrogram analysis was conducted with VS9700 phone workstation 1.0 software.The consonants were charactered by the presence rates of vertical or disarrayed striations as well as the blank interspace of consonant structures.All the patients were observed before and after speech training in the presence rates of consonant and clinical characteristics of speech disorder;Meanwhile,the comprehensive speech therapy that aimed directly at speech disorder was underwent,including trainings of velopharyngeal closure function,enhancing continence expiration function and strengthening exact articulation organs.The treatment duration was one or two times in one week at early period,and then once every two weeks at later period,30-60 minutes for one time,totally for 3-6 months.In addition,the phonetic index was compared before and after receiving training.RESULTS:Sixteen patients were all involved in the result analysis.①The main vocal characteristics on the postoperative cleft palate patient with speech disorder in clinical were the structural asophia(6 cases,38%)due to the incomplete function of velopharyngeal closure,was expressed as rhinorrhea,hypernasality in both initials and finals;the functional speech disorders(16 cases,100%)resulting from the bad compensatory phonological habit,was expressed as palatal articulation(16 cases,100%),lateral articulation(14 cases,88%),nasopharyngeal articulation(13 cases,81%)and initial distortion(16 cases,100%),16 permutations(100%)or 14 omits(88%);the speech-breath disorder(4 cases,25.0%),expressed as the shortening of the longest sound.②The mean intelligibility of the patients was enhanced from 32.63% to 79.50%,and there were significant differences between the scores of articulation before and after speech therapy(P < 0.001).③The features of syllable spectrogram were obviously improved after speech training(P < 0.05).CONCLUSION:The main vocal characteristics of the postoperative cleft palate patient are the functional speech disorders because of the bad compensatory phonological habit.Speech therapy can improve the linguistic development of the patients significantly.Computer spectrum analysis is an effective method for evaluating the speech characteristics and the treatment efficacy.