Abstract:"Culture of honor" means that individuals deter others by signaling their commitment to violent retaliation. We develop a multilevel explanation of cross-level interdependence of honor and violence. According to our concept of system-level honor, a social system is loaded with deterrence signaling if culture of honor is highly prevalent in the system. In line with the Smith and Price (1973, in Nature, https://www.nature.com/articles/246015a0 ) model, we argue that high system-level honor discourages Prober-Retaliator behavior: some individuals might tend to challenge others they assume to be inferior to increase their own reputation. Both individual culture of honor and system-level honor contribute to an increase in violence (H1; H2). However, as system-level honor and deterrence become more prevalent, the impact of individual honor diminishes because engaging in violent behavior becomes increasingly expensive within such a system (H3). As a second contextual effect, inequality in culture of honor should therefore increase violent behavior because it encourages Prober-Retaliator behavior (H4). We analyze the effect of culture of honor on school violence among 15-year-old adolescents. Disentangling the micro- and context-level effects of culture of honor on violent behavior in a multilevel analysis framework allows the estimation of a cross-level interaction using a large data set from more than 25,000 adolescents in more than 1,300 schoolroom contexts. Results are in line with our H3, but not with H4. Model-based predictions show that the deterrent effect must be unrealistically high to generate an equilibrium of average violence.

Punches or Punchlines? Honor, Face, and Dignity Cultures Encourage Different Reactions to Provocation

Contextual and Cultural Differences in Positive Thinking

How are Responses to Verbal Insult Related to Cultural Collectivism and Power Distance?

The Impact of Culture and Identity on Emotional Reactions to Insults

Culture As Perceived Context: an Exploration of the Distinction Between Dignity, Face and Honor Cultures

Coercion and Provocation

Relationships between individualism-collectivism, gender, and direct or indirect aggression: a study in China, Poland, and the US

Preferred responses when honour is at stake: The role of cultural background, presence of others, and causality orientation

A Cross-Cultural Analysis of Argument Predispositions in China: Argumentativeness, Verbal Aggressiveness, Argument Frames, and Personalization of Conflict

To Be or Not to Be Humorous? Cross Cultural Perspectives on Humor

Culture and Procedural Justice: The Influence of Power Distance on Reactions to Voice

Dignity, Face, and Honor Cultures: A Study of Negotiation Strategy and Outcomes in Three Cultures

Honor in the Wild : Virtuous Violence between the Hobbesian Trap and Social Order

Fear Goliath or David? Inferring Competence From Demeanor Across Cultures.

The Impact of Culture and Social Distance on Humor Appreciation, Sharing, and Production

Power Distance and Facework Strategies

Who Approves of Gossip, Ostracism, and Confrontation Following Norm Violations? A Cross-Cultural Test of Gender Stereotypes

Culture Moderates the Cardiovascular Consequences of Anger Regulation Strategy

Geysers or Bubbling Hot Springs? A Cross-Cultural Examination of Customer Rage From Eastern and Western Perspectives

Group punishment does not always discount: Cultural difference in punishment of individuals and groups

"Stand up for yourself!" Masculine honor beliefs and expectations for bullied youth