Contextual and Cultural Differences in Positive Thinking

Li-Jun Ji,Thomas I. Vaughan-Johnston,Zhiyong Zhang,Jill A. Jacobson,Ning Zhang,Xiaoye Huang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/00220221211020442

2021-01-01

Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology

Abstract:Past research suggests that East Asians engage in less positive thinking than Westerners, but cultural differences in positive thinking may depend on context. The present research investigates how culture and context may interactively influence positive thinking. In Studies 1 ( N = 287) and 2 ( N = 245), participants read hypothetical positive or negative events, and indicated their endorsement of responses to each event that reflected positive versus negative thinking. Chinese more often than Euro-Canadians endorsed relatively negative thinking in response to positive events and relatively positive thinking in response to negative events. In Study 3 ( N = 573), Chinese (versus Euro-Canadians) generated more negative outcomes for positive events and more positive outcomes for negative events. These effects were mediated by lay theory of change, a belief that events change over time nonlinearly. The findings use diverse measurement approaches to highlight the importance of examining positive thinking in context across cultures.