Comparison Between Predilation Stenting and Direct Stenting in the Treatment of Aged Patients with Coronary Heart Disease
卢才义,王士雯,胡桃红,刘玲玲,晏沐阳,李玉峰,黄从春,陈瑞,刘鹏
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1671-5403.2003.02.008
2003-01-01
Abstract:Objective To evaluate the efficacy of optimal predilation stenting, suboptimal predilation stenting and direct stenting in the treatment of aged patients with acute coronary syndrome. Methods Patients with following characteristics were enrolled into the study: ①unstable angina pectoris or non ST elevation myocardial infarction; ②older than 65 years; ③without diabetes mellitus; ④target coronary lesion was stenosis of 75-95% , ≤30mm in length, ≥3.0mm in reference vessel diameter, ≤45° angulation and moderate calcification. The patients were randomized into following groups: ①stenting with complete predilation (SCP group): stent was implanted in lesion site after complete predilation with 1: 1 balloon to reference vessel diameter; ②stenting with incomplete predilation (SIP group) : stem was implanted in lesion site after incomplete predilation with a balloon 20-30% smaller than reference vessel diameter; ③stenting without predilation (SWP group): stent was implanted in lesion site without predilation. Ticlopidine was used for 4 weeks. Other medications such as β-blocker, calcium antagonist agent, ACEI and statins were continued. Clinical presentation and ECG were followed up semiannually. Repeated coronary angiography was conducted selectively for patients with reccurrent chest pain or myocardial ischemia attack. Results One hundred and ninety-eight patients (263 target lesions) with mean age of 72 ± 11 were enrolled. In SCP group, 87 lesions (63 patients) were stented successfully. In this group 33 major dissections (33.3%) were treated with bail-out stenting. In SIP group, 88 stents were implanted in 69 patients with 9 minor dissections. In SWP group, 88 target lesions were successfully stented in 66 patients. During follow-up of (15.2 ± 5.3) months, there was no case of death and myocardial infarction. Twelve patients (6.2%) received coronary angiography due to chest pain and myocardial ischemia. Of them, 5 cases (4 in SCP and 1 in SIP) had target lesion restenosis, three cases had aggravation of non-target lesion and 4 cases kept coronary artery patent. Conclusions ①In aged patients with non-occluded target coronary lesion, stenting with and without complete and incomplete predilation had the equal success rate. ②Complete predilation had high dissection rate, bail-out stenting rate and long-term restenosis rate. Direct stenting had shortest procedure time, lowest cost and less restenosis rate.③It is not advocated to attempt complete predilation to obtain stent-like balloon dilation effect in aged. ④Stenting after imcomplete predilation can be used as regular procedure in old patients with coronary disease.