A Nonexistent Tradition: On CHEN Shixiang's Lyrical Tradition
G Peng-cheng
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.2095-0012.2013.03.007
2013-01-01
Journal of Aesthetic Education
Abstract:"China's lyrical tradition" which summarized Mr. Chen Shixiang's basic views on Chinese literature and produced a huge impact later on became a highly comprehensive explanatory system after being propounded in turn by Gao Yougong, Lv Zhenghui, Ko Qingming, Zheng Yuyu and etc. But this is an established opinion with which I have always disagreed. First, in this argument, Chinese poetry is made to fit the Western genre of lyrics and said to possess this very lyricism, so much so that lyrical poetry is the tradition or even orthodoxy of Chinese literature. Such an argument, I venture to say, is a methodological and logical error, because it is one thing to call something a characteristic and quite another to say whether it constitutes a tradition or an orthodoxy and (even if it does) how this comes about. Second, Mr. Chen attempted to use the model of Western lyrical poetry to explain Chinese literature. Third, Mr Chen failed to realize that Chinese literature and Western Romanticist literature differ both in the manners in which feelings are expressed and in the feelings themselves. To conclude, Mr Chen was not free from blunders in understanding Chinese poetry and traditional Chinese thought. The lyrical tradition that he traced in Chinese literature is nonexistent.