Abstract:After victory in the Anti-Japanese War, Chiang Kai-shek issued the famous radio speech “Letter to Soldiers and Civilians of the Whole Nation as well as the Peoples of the World after the Victory of the Anti-Japanese War.” The main idea of this speech was long interpreted as “returning virtue for malice” (or “good for evil”), a basic principle of the Kuomintang's policy towards Japan. Many scholars who have considered the returning virtue for malice policy in the postwar period include the following major issues: first, China repatriated Japanese prisoners of war and the Japanese diaspora with mercy; second, China allowed the Tenno, or imperial, system to be preserved in Japan; third, China did not participate in the occupation of Japan; and fourth, China gave up the right to ask for war reparations from Japan. This article examines the above four issues to reevaluate the returning virtue for malice policy. The first issue seems to reflect the Chinese national character of being lenient with others. However, it was in fact due to Chiang's anti-Communist strategy and the declared policy of the United States of eradicating Japan's influence in China. With regard to the second issue, Chiang's attitude was merely to let the Japanese people make their own choice, while the fate of the Japanese Tenno system was entirely determined by the US occupation authority, on which Chiang had little influence. The third issue was mainly the outcome of Chiang's focus on domestic political struggle in the postwar era in China. As for war reparations, China actually made efforts to obtain them in the beginning, but had to give up its right eventually. The decision-making process in the Kuomintang government was restrained by American policy and subordinated to Japanese pressure. Thus, it is not persuasive to summarize the basic principle of Kuomintang postwar policy towards Japan as returning virtue for malice.

Reassessing the Yuan Shikai’s Secret Report during the Coup Against the Hundred Days Reform

Qian Xun: "Extraordinary Talent" in Diplomatic History of Late Qing Dynasty——Concurrently on Untenable Assumption of "Zhang Zhidong's Imperial Dream"

Yuan Shikai and the Restoration of Tianjin at the Turn of the Twentieth Century

Reflections upon the Centennial Abolition of the Imperial Examination System

Yuan Shikai and the Education of Officials and the Gentry in the Late Qing Dynasty

Liang Qichao's Comment on “the Internal Debt of Yuan Shikai's Type”

Another Interpretation of Abolishing Imperial Examination and Initiating Schools in the Late Qing Dynasty—— Reading Notes on Zhu Shisan's Diary(1893-1919)

The Dispute over the Emperor Guangxu's Ascending to the Throne

Shi Liangcai’s Death Recorded in Huang Yanpei ’s Diary

On the Case of Teng Zijing

Viewing from Another Angle:A Rethinking on the Fall of the Qing Dynasty

An Analyzing Study of Liang Qichao's "revolution" Conception in 1915-1916

Dispute about Puyi and the death of Ouyang Xiu

Historical Truth and Interpretive Guidance in the Linqing Incident on the Eve of the Establishment of New China

A Re-analysis of the Chinese Communist Party's Response to the Fujian Incident

A Study on the Assassination of Song Jiaoren in 1913

From the Hundred Days' Reform (1898) to the New Policies at the End of the Qing Dynasty ----The Imperial University of Peking in a Time of Drastic Change

The re-examination of Chiang Kai-shek's returning virtue for malice policy towards Japan after the victory of the Anti-Japanese War

On Cai Yuanpei's Taking Up the Post of Peking University's President

Yuan Shikai and Sino-Foreign Negotiations about Mining Rights of Zhili Province in Late Qing

The Court Battle Between the System and Human Relationships in Beiyang Period