Abstract:Although narcissists often emerge as leaders, the relationship between leader narcissism and follower performance is ambiguous and often even found to be negative. For women, narcissism seems especially likely to lead to negative evaluations. Since narcissists have the tendency to be impulsive and change their minds on a whim, they may come across as inconsistent. We propose “inconsistent leader behavior” as a new mechanism in the relationship between leader narcissism and follower performance and argue that leader gender plays an important role in whether narcissistic leaders are perceived as inconsistent. Specifically, we expect leader narcissism to have a negative relationship with follower performance through perceived inconsistent leader behavior, especially for female leaders. Thus, we examine leader gender as a personal factor moderating the relationship between narcissism and perceived inconsistent behavior. Also, as perceived inconsistency is likely less problematic when a good relationship exists, we examine leader–member exchange (LMX) as a contextual condition moderating the relationship between leader behavior and follower performance. We test our moderated mediation model in a multi-source study with 165 unique leader–follower dyads. As expected, leader narcissism was positively related to perceived inconsistent leader behavior, and this relationship was stronger for female leaders. Inconsistent leader behavior was negatively related to follower performance, but only when LMX was low. Our research highlights that perceived behavioral inconsistency can be problematic and—for female leaders—provides an explanation of the negative relation of leader narcissism with follower performance and of the inconsistencies in evaluations of narcissistic leaders’ effectiveness.

How Do Leaders React when Treated Unfairly? Leader Narcissism and Self-Interested Behavior in Response to Unfair Treatment

Communal Narcissism: Social Decisions and Neurophysiological Reactions

Selfless Leader and Their Selfless Follower: the Trickle-Down Effect of Leader Perceived Fairness

Leadership Justice and Negative Organizational Behaviors: Mediated by Affective Commitment

Relative Leader-Member Exchange and Unethical Pro-leader Behavior: the Role of Envy and Distributive Justice Climate

Author Response for "how Does Leader Self‐sacrifice Lead to Employees' Unethical Pro‐organizational Behavior? A Moderated Mediation Model"

Relative Leader-member Exchange and Unethical Pro-leader Behavior: A Cross-level Moderated Mediation

How Does Leader Anger Expression Towards Unethical Behavior Impact Team OCB?

When narcissists exemplify ethics: Contingent consequences of ethical leadership.

The Impact of Narcissistic Leader on Subordinates and Team Followership: Based on “Guanxi” Perspective

Both a curse and a blessing? A social cognitive approach to the paradoxical effects of leader narcissism

How Narcissistic Leaders Impact on Subordinate’s Followership During the COVID-19? The Moderating Role of Organizational Identification

When Self‐love is Threatened: Adopting a Dual‐type View to Understand Leader Narcissism and Its Impacts on LMX and Newcomer Work Outcomes

Research on the Effect of Narcissistic Leadership on Employee Job Embeddedness

An Emotional Desert? Leader Narcissism, Affective Events, and Affect-Laden Leader Behaviors

Man in the mirror? Exploring the influence of leader and follower narcissism (in)congruence on follower voice

Perceived Abusive Leadership, Narcissistic Personality, and Employee's Political Behaviors: A Moderated-Mediation Model

Are Narcissistic Subordinates More Silent? Exploring the Destructive Effect of Narcissistic Leadership on Subordinate Job Performance

Narcissistic Enough to Challenge: The Effect of Narcissism on Change-Oriented Organizational Citizenship Behavior

Effects of Leader Narcissism on Career Success of Employees: An Interpersonal Relationship Perspective

Gender Differences in the Perceived Behavior of Narcissistic Leaders