Abstract:Although narcissists often emerge as leaders, the relationship between leader narcissism and follower performance is ambiguous and often even found to be negative. For women, narcissism seems especially likely to lead to negative evaluations. Since narcissists have the tendency to be impulsive and change their minds on a whim, they may come across as inconsistent. We propose “inconsistent leader behavior” as a new mechanism in the relationship between leader narcissism and follower performance and argue that leader gender plays an important role in whether narcissistic leaders are perceived as inconsistent. Specifically, we expect leader narcissism to have a negative relationship with follower performance through perceived inconsistent leader behavior, especially for female leaders. Thus, we examine leader gender as a personal factor moderating the relationship between narcissism and perceived inconsistent behavior. Also, as perceived inconsistency is likely less problematic when a good relationship exists, we examine leader–member exchange (LMX) as a contextual condition moderating the relationship between leader behavior and follower performance. We test our moderated mediation model in a multi-source study with 165 unique leader–follower dyads. As expected, leader narcissism was positively related to perceived inconsistent leader behavior, and this relationship was stronger for female leaders. Inconsistent leader behavior was negatively related to follower performance, but only when LMX was low. Our research highlights that perceived behavioral inconsistency can be problematic and—for female leaders—provides an explanation of the negative relation of leader narcissism with follower performance and of the inconsistencies in evaluations of narcissistic leaders’ effectiveness.

Man in the mirror? Exploring the influence of leader and follower narcissism (in)congruence on follower voice

Paradoxical Effects of Narcissism on Creative Performance: Roles of Leader–follower Narcissism (in)congruence and Follower Identification with the Leader

Both a curse and a blessing? A social cognitive approach to the paradoxical effects of leader narcissism

Echo ‘our’ Voice? the Influences of Team Members on the Voice Behavior of Focal Employees

The Impact of Narcissistic Leader on Subordinates and Team Followership: Based on “Guanxi” Perspective

How and when Perceived Leader Narcissism Impacts Employee Voice Behavior: a Social Exchange Perspective

When Self‐love is Threatened: Adopting a Dual‐type View to Understand Leader Narcissism and Its Impacts on LMX and Newcomer Work Outcomes

Narcissism Congruence and Employee Creative Performance: the Role of Psychological Empowerment

Effects of Leader Narcissism on Career Success of Employees: An Interpersonal Relationship Perspective

How and When Does Leader Humility Enhance Employee Proactive Career Behavior

Supervisor Narcissism and Employee Performance: A Moderated Mediation Model of Affective Organizational Commitment and Power Distance Orientation

How Narcissistic Leaders Impact on Subordinate’s Followership During the COVID-19? The Moderating Role of Organizational Identification

Are Narcissistic Subordinates More Silent? Exploring the Destructive Effect of Narcissistic Leadership on Subordinate Job Performance

When narcissists exemplify ethics: Contingent consequences of ethical leadership.

Gender Differences in the Perceived Behavior of Narcissistic Leaders

The Divergent and Bidirectional Relationships Between Narcissistic Admiration and Rivalry and Prosocial Behaviors

Multifaceted leaders: the double-edged sword effect of narcissistic leadership on employees' work behavior

Leader-Follower Congruence in Proactive Personality and Work Outcomes: the Mediating Role of Leader-Member Exchange

Influence of Relationship Conflicts with Leaders and Coworkers on Employees' Voice

In Leaders We Trust, or Should We? Supervisors’ Dark Triad Personality Traits and Ratings of Team Performance and Innovation