Why and when is Narcissistic Leader Harmful: Exploring Mediating Mechanisms and Boundary Conditions
Lei Huang,Debra L. Shapiro,Randall S Peterson,Joel B. Carnevale,Jack Ting-Ju Chiang,Quan Li,Brad Paul Owens,Justin Ames,Bruce Avolio,Pierre Balthazard,Li Guo,Fong T. Keng,Joohyung Kim,Haiyang Liu,Zhuolin She,Lynne Catherine Vincent,Raseana Williams,Lingtao Yu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5465/ambpp.2019.11470symposium
2019-01-01
Abstract:Prior findings suggest that narcissistic leaders harm the development of positive relationships and their associated positive work-behaviors. Yet, in contrast to this, narcissistic leaders sometimes behave in ways that show consideration for, and appreciation of, others (e.g., by showing humility, consulting subordinates before making decisions affecting them) - hence in ways that deviate from their dispositional tendencies. These deviations may explain why narcissistic leaders have sometimes been described by their subordinates as visionary or charismatic leaders who can lead their work unit to greater long-term success. When do narcissistic leaders display humility versus self-centered (harming) behaviors, and relatedly, what variables (potentially relating to leaders and/or their followers) weaken versus strengthen leader narcissism effects? What mechanisms account for when narcissistic leaders produce more or less workplace harms? This symposium aims at answering these questions and thus alerting scholars to new theories, empirical methods, and heretofore unstudied moderators and mediators of leader narcissism-dynamics. Outshined and Envious Narcissistic Leaders: A Self-Evaluation Maintenance Perspective Presenter: Joel B. Carnevale; Syracuse U. Presenter: Lei Huang; Auburn U. Presenter: Lynne Catherine Vincent; Syracuse U. Presenter: Lingtao Yu; U. of British Columbia EEG Contrasts of Paradoxical Self-Referential Traits: Narcissism and Humility Presenter: Brad Paul Owens; Brigham Young U. Presenter: Justin Ames; Case Western Reserve U. Presenter: Raseana Williams; Arizona State U. Presenter: Joohyung Kim; Arizona State U. Presenter: Pierre Balthazard; California State U. Sacramento Differences in Narcissists’ Tendency to Devalue Others and Subsequent Punishment Severity Presenter: Jack Ting-Ju Chiang; Peking U. Presenter: Haiyang Liu; London School of Economics and Political Science Presenter: Fong T. Keng; Nanyang Technological U. Presenter: Li Guo; Guanghua School of Management, Peking U. Presenter: Bruce Avolio; U. of Washington A Narcissistic Leader Meets A Narcissistic Follower: Role of Relational Conflict and Goal Congruence Presenter: Quan Li; Tsinghua SEM Presenter: Zhuolin She; Tsinghua SEM Presenter: Debra L. Shapiro; U. of Maryland