Abstract:There hasn't been much exchange of ideas between economists and philosophers of economics. This is understandable to some extent, given that the primary focus of these communities is different. Most economists show little interest in the general and abstract methodological issues that philosophers of economics typically explore, for example, and conversely most philosophers of economics do not seem to be very interested in the practical, 'bread and butter' decisions that pre-occupy economists in their professional practices. But there are exceptions, such as the series of papers Itzhak Gilboa, Andrew Postlewaite, Larry Samuelson, and David Schmeidler (GPSS) have been publishing on how economists think about their own modelling practices (Gilboa et al., Citation 2014 , Citation 2018 , Citation 2019 , Citation 2023 ). These papers for sure fall within the orbit of interest of philosophers of economics. Yet direct and explicit engagement with the work of GPSS by philosophers of economics has been largely missing. When we saw a working paper by GPSS on economic methodology circulating some three years ago, we thought that it would provide a nice opportunity to organize an open exchange with prominent philosophers of economics. Hence, we contacted GPSS to invite them to submit this as a target article for a special issue. Although this working paper was submitted to another journal (Gilboa et al. Citation 2023 ), GPSS kindly offered to write a new article for JEM, outlining their views. After their article was published online, we invited a diverse set of authors with expertise on this topic to provide commentaries. Many of those invited graciously agreed to submit their commentary. While the process, including submission of the articles and peer review, took longer than anticipated, we are proud to present this special issue at the end of 2024.

Economic models and their flexible interpretations: a philosophy of science perspective

Economic models as argumentative devices

On the contents and agents of commentary in modelling

Economic Modelling As Robustness Analysis

Insider apology for microeconomic theorising?

Reflections on Econometric Modeling Methodology

The normative decision theory in economics: a philosophy of science perspective. The case of the expected utility theory

An Interdisciplinary Model for Macroeconomics

Model Uncertainty in Climate Change Economics: A Review and Proposed Framework for Future Research

Homo economicus to model human behavior is ethically doubtful and mathematically inconsistent

Introduction to the special issue: economic theories and their dueling interpretations

'Let me tell you a story': the politics of macroeconomic models

Modeling the social organization of science

Crises and collective socio-economic phenomena: simple models and challenges

'Managing values' in health economics modelling: Philosophical and practical considerations

Are models our tools not our masters?

Modelling Bounded Rationality in Organizations: Progress and Prospects

Evolutionary models in economics: a survey of methods and building blocks

Mathematical Representation in Economics and Finance: Philosophical Preference, Mathematical Simplicity, and Empirical Relevance

Physics and Financial Economics (1776-2014): Puzzles, Ising and Agent-Based models

Designing a Homo Psychologicus More Psychologicus: Empirical Results on Value Perception in Support to a New Theoretical Organizational-Economic Agent Based Model