Abstract:Previous neurofeedback research has shown training-related frontal theta increases and performance improvements on some executive tasks in real feedback versus sham control groups. However, typical sham control groups receive false or non-contingent feedback, making it difficult to know whether observed differences between groups are associated with accurate contingent feedback or other cognitive mechanisms (motivation, control strategies, attentional engagement, fatigue, etc.). To address this question, we investigated differences between two frontal theta training groups, each receiving accurate contingent feedback, but with different top-down goals: (1) increase and (2) alternate increase/decrease. We hypothesized that the increase group would exhibit greater increases in frontal theta compared to the alternate group, which would exhibit lower frontal theta during down- versus up-modulation blocks over sessions. We also hypothesized that the alternate group would exhibit greater performance improvements on a Go-NoGo shooting task requiring alterations in behavioral activation and inhibition, as the alternate group would be trained with greater task specificity, suggesting that receiving accurate contingent feedback may be the more salient learning mechanism underlying frontal theta neurofeedback training gains. Thirty young healthy volunteers were randomly assigned to increase or alternate groups. Training consisted of an orientation session, five neurofeedback training sessions (six blocks of six 30-s trials of FCz theta modulation (4–7 Hz) separated by 10-s rest intervals), and six Go-NoGo testing sessions (four blocks of 90 trials in both Low and High time-stress conditions). Multilevel modeling revealed greater frontal theta increases in the alternate group over training sessions. Further, Go-NoGo task performance increased at a greater rate in the increase group (accuracy and reaction time, but not commission errors). Overall, these results reject our hypotheses and suggest that changes in frontal theta and performance outcomes were not explained by reinforcement learning afforded by accurate contingent feedback. We discuss our findings in terms of alternative conceptual and methodological considerations, as well as limitations of this research.

To Know or Not to Know? Theta and Delta Reflect Complementary Information about an Advanced Cue Before Feedback in Decision-Making

Time-frequency Analysis of Electroencephalogram Signals in a Cognitive Decision-making Task

Frontal Theta Oscillatory Activity Is a Common Mechanism for the Computation of Unexpected Outcomes and Learning Rate

Feedback-related Brain Activity in Individual Decision: Evidence from a Gambling EEG Study.

Modulating the Activity of the DLPFC and OFC Has Distinct Effects on Risk and Ambiguity Decision-Making: A Tdcs Study

Oscillatory Profiles Of Positive, Negative And Neutral Feedback Stimuli During Adaptive Decision Making

Electrophysiological measures reveal the role of anterior cingulate cortex in learning from unreliable feedback

Decision-Feedback Stages Revealed by Hidden Markov Modeling of EEG.

The role of brain oscillatory activity in processing the informative value of feedback during rule acquisition

Frontal cortex electrophysiology in reward- and punishment-related feedback processing during advice-guided decision making: An interleaved EEG-DC stimulation study

Cue Predictiveness and Uncertainty Determine Cue Representation During Visual Statistical Learning.

Common and distinct electrophysiological correlates of feedback processing during risky and ambiguous decision making

Brain-to-brain coupling forecasts future joint action outcomes

Theta Oscillations Index Frontal Decision-Making and Mediate Reciprocal Frontal-Parietal Interactions in Willed Attention

How an uncertain cue modulates subsequent monetary outcome evaluation: an ERP study.

How Instructed Knowledge Modulates the Neural Systems of Reward Learning

Response-locked theta dissociations reveal potential feedback signal following successful retrieval

Neural Oscillation Correlates Chemistry Decision-Making

Fluctuations in alpha and beta power provide neural states favourable for contextually relevant anticipatory processes

Behavioral Analysis of EEG Signals in Loss-Gain Decision-Making Experiments

Neural and behavioral adaptations to frontal theta neurofeedback training: A proof of concept study