THE ECONOMIC IMPACT OF BETTER HEAT EXCHANGER CLEANING ON AN OIL REFINERY – THEORETICAL, EXPECTED AND ACTUAL RESULTS.

E. Diaz-Bejarano,B. N. Kieser,R. Tomotaki,F. Coletti,J. Loyola-Fuentes
Abstract:Ultrasonic cleaning of heat exchangers has been in use since at least 2009 [1]. As a cleaning method, it has been shown to provide superior results over traditional hydroblasting techniques, offering better and faster cleaning, with improved safety and a drastic reduction in water use [1,2,3,4]. Despite the apparent benefits, there remains institutional doubt about the actual value that better cleaning can bring to the industry. Anecdotally, and in at least two publications, [2,5,6] operators have reported apparent improvements in cleaning results of 10-25%, and an improvement in the economic benefits of cleaning of well over US$1M per exchanger cleaned. This paper presents an attempt to validate these reports using real customer data and a Hexxcell Hybrid Digital Twin model of the hot end of a pre-heat train in a 110,000 bbl/day refinery. We now have data from measured trials conducted in the United States in which operators have provided historical and on-going performance data which allows a detailed comparison of heat exchanger performance pre-and post-cleaning, with both hydroblasting and ultrasonic methods. The results support expectations, showing an improvement in post-cleaning performance of between 0-40%, with an average improvement of about 20%. The data collected thus far suggests a fuel-reduction energy savings value of up to US$700,000
Environmental Science,Engineering,Economics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?