Abstract:Multilevel models allow researchers to test hypotheses at multiple levels of analysis-for example, assessing the effects of both individual-level and school-level predictors on a target outcome. To assess these effects with the greatest clarity, researchers are well-advised to cluster mean center all Level 1 predictors and explicitly incorporate the cluster means into the model at Level 2. When an outcome of interest is continuous, this unconflated model specification serves both to increase model accuracy, by separating the level-specific effects of each predictor, and to increase model interpretability, by reframing the random intercepts as unadjusted cluster means. When an outcome of interest is binary or ordinal, however, only the first of these benefits is fully realized: In these models, the intuitive cluster mean interpretations of Level 2 effects are only available on the metric of the linear predictor (e.g., the logit) or, equivalently, the latent response propensity, yij∗. Because the calculations for obtaining predicted probabilities, odds, and ORs operate on the entire combined model equation, the interpretations of these quantities are inextricably tied to individual-level, rather than cluster-level, outcomes. This is unfortunate, given that the probability and odds metrics are often of greatest interest to researchers in practice. To address this issue, I propose a novel rescaling method designed to calculate cluster average success proportions, odds, and ORs in two-level binary and ordinal logistic and probit models. I apply the approach to a real data example and provide supplemental R functions to help users implement the method easily. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2024 APA, all rights reserved).

The Fragility Of Standard Inferential Approaches In Principal Stratification Models Relative To Direct Likelihood Approaches

A direct likelihood approach to principal stratification analysis

Empirical-Likelihood-Based Inference for Partially Linear Models

Fully Latent Principal Stratification With Measurement Models

Partial identification of principal causal effects under violations of principal ignorability

PStrata: An R Package for Principal Stratification

Marginal Likelihood Computation for Model Selection and Hypothesis Testing: An Extensive Review

Tricks with metrics: combining statistics for improved inference in regression analysis

On the choice of the splitting ratio for the split likelihood ratio test

Empirical Likelihood for Partially Linear Single-Index Errors-In-Variables Model

Principal stratification with continuous treatments and continuous post-treatment variables

Individual-level probabilities and cluster-level proportions: Toward interpretable level 2 estimates in unconflated multilevel models for binary outcomes.

Intrinsic tests for the equality of two correlated proportions

Empirical Likelihood for Linear Models with Missing Responses

Statistical Inference on Asymptotic Properties of Two Estimators for the Partially Linear Single-Index Models

Parsimony in Model Selection: Tools for Assessing Fit Propensity

An efficient asymptotic approach for testing monotone proportions assuming an underlying logit based order dose-response model

Bayesian Nonparametrics for Principal Stratification with Continuous Post-Treatment Variables

Uncertainty of Statistical Models and Propensity Score Methods

Empirical Correction to the Likelihood Ratio Statistic for Structural Equation Modeling with Many Variables

Bayesian Framework for Causal Inference with Principal Stratification and Clusters