Abstract:Astyanax mexicanus is a freshwater fish species with blind cave morphs and sighted surface morphs. Like other troglodytic species, independently evolved cave-dwelling A. mexicanus populations share several stereotypic phenotypes, including the expansion of certain sensory systems, as well as the loss of eyes and pigmentation. Here, we assess the extent to which there is also parallelism in craniofacial development across cave populations. Since multiple forces may be acting upon variation in the A. mexicanus system, including phylogenetic history, selection, and developmental constraint, several outcomes are possible. For example, eye regression may have triggered a conserved series of compensatory developmental events, in which case we would expect to observe highly similar craniofacial phenotypes across cave populations. Selection for cave-specific foraging may also lead to the evolution of a conserved craniofacial phenotype, especially in regions of the head directly associated with feeding. Alternatively, in the absence of a common axis of selection or strong developmental constraints, craniofacial shape may evolve under neutral processes such as gene flow, drift, and bottlenecking, in which case patterns of variation should reflect the evolutionary history of A. mexicanus. Our results found that cave-adapted populations do share certain anatomical features; however, they generally did not support the hypothesis of a conserved craniofacial phenotype across caves, as nearly every pairwise comparison was statistically significant, with greater effect sizes noted between more distantly related cave populations with little gene flow. A similar pattern was observed for developmental trajectories. We also found that morphological disparity was lower among all three cave populations versus surface fish, suggesting eye loss is not associated with increased variation, which would be consistent with a release of developmental constraint. Instead, this pattern reflects the relatively low genetic diversity within cave populations. Finally, magnitudes of craniofacial integration were found to be similar among all groups, meaning that coordinated development among anatomical units is robust to eye loss in A. mexicanus. We conclude that, in contrast to many conserved phenotypes across cave populations, global craniofacial shape is more variable, and patterns of shape variation are more in line with population structure than developmental architecture or selection.

Brain Size Variation in Extremophile Fish: Local Adaptation Versus Phenotypic Plasticity

Toxic Hydrogen Sulphide Shapes Brain Anatomy: A Comparative Study of Sulphide-Adapted Ecotypes in the Poecilia Mexicana Complex

An Adult Brain Atlas Reveals Broad Neuroanatomical Changes in Independently Evolved Populations of Mexican Cavefish

Cavefish brain atlases reveal functional and anatomical convergence across independently evolved populations

Large brain in undisturbed headwaters: validation of general evolutionary predictions from a local-scale perspective

Effects of plasticity and genetic divergence in phenotypic trait expression of sulfide spring fishes

Multiple within species comparisons show Tanganyikan cichlid fish have larger brains in less structurally complex habitats

Local Adaptation and Pronounced Genetic Differentiation in an Extremophile Fish, Poecilia Mexicana, Inhabiting A Mexican Cave with Toxic Hydrogen Sulphide

Microhabitat use affects brain size and structure in intertidal gobies

Beyond the mosaic model of brain evolution: Rearing environment defines local and global plasticity

Experimental translocations to low predation lead to non-parallel increases in relative brain size

Comparative support for the expensive tissue hypothesis: Big brains are correlated with smaller gut and greater parental investment in Lake Tanganyika cichlids

Predation drives the evolution of brain cell proliferation and brain allometry in male Trinidadian killifish, Rivulus hartii

Toxic hydrogen sulfide and dark caves: phenotypic and genetic divergence across two abiotic environmental gradients in Poecilia mexicana.

Evolutionary divergence of plasticity in brain morphology between ecologically divergent habitats of Trinidadian guppies

Predation impacts brain allometry in female guppies (Poecilia reticulata)

Population comparisons reveal more social interactions are correlated with larger brains in the Lake Tanganyikan cichlid Neolamprologus brevis

Evolution in Caves: Selection from Darkness Causes Spinal Deformities in Teleost Fishes.

Unravelling the origins of boldness behaviour: a common garden experiment with cavefish (Barbatula barbatula)

Effects of extreme habitat conditions on otolith morphology: a case study on extremophile live bearing fishes (Poecilia mexicana, P. sulphuraria).

Variable Craniofacial Shape and Development among Multiple Cave-Adapted Populations of Astyanax mexicanus