Large brain in undisturbed headwaters: validation of general evolutionary predictions from a local-scale perspective

Horký, Pavel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10682-024-10320-5

IF: 2.074

2024-11-10

Evolutionary Ecology

Abstract:Differences in brain size among homeothermic vertebrates are known to have important ecological and evolutionary consequences, involving trade-offs between the cognitive benefits of larger brains and the associated energetic costs. Nonetheless, other poikilothermic vertebrate groups have been largely overlooked in this context, challenging the broad applicability of the proposed theories for vertebrates more generally. Fish brains are highly plastic organs that adapt to environmental conditions, so we focused on local-scale validation based on comparisons of species from the undisturbed headwaters of Šumava National Park, Czech Republic. The brains of common minnows ( Phoxinus phoxinus L.), brown trout ( Salmo trutta m. fario L.) and European bullheads ( Cottus gobio L.) were scanned via computed tomography. Our aim was to determine whether the brain size patterns of these three species, which are unrelated at the level of phylogenetic order and occur naturally in a single locality without significant anthropogenic pressures, follow general predictions. The cognitive buffer hypothesis, which suggests that large brains provide a behavioural buffer facilitating successful introduction to new environments, was confirmed, as brown trout and minnows, i.e., species with invasive potential, had larger brains than non-invasive, stationary bullheads. This confirmation provides new support for the general validity of the cognitive buffer hypothesis across vertebrates. However, our results were not in alignment with the parental brain hypothesis. The patterns of sensory areas of the brain also measured in the present study (i.e., the olfactory bulb, optic tectum and eminentia granularis) indicate that minnows invest more in the development of the sensory areas of the brain and, thus, primary sensory processing, whereas trout invest in cognitive and integrative processing. The present study emphasises that general evolutionary predictions and theories regarding brain size, especially in fish, should also be verified at a local scale with comparable ecological conditions across species.

ecology,genetics & heredity,evolutionary biology