Pragmatic Interpretation of the English Present Perfect

Xinyue Yao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/ling-2013-0035

2013-01-01

Linguistics

Abstract:Abstract This article discusses the interpretation of the English present perfect adopting a pragmatic approach. I show that a full interpretation of the English present perfect requires identification of the nature of current relevance, or, within a perfect state account (e.g., Nishiyama and Koenig 2010), value-assignment for a present state. I argue that the specific value of the present state is either an explicature or an implicature of the utterance containing the present perfect. The difference between such interpretations as continuative, resultative and experiential perfects, on a pragmatic level, lies in the content of the explicatures they express. I further argue that this process of value-assignment should be understood in light of the relevance-theoretic account of communication (Sperber and Wilson 1995 [1986]; Wilson and Sperber 2002, 2004). It entails, on the part of the speaker, communication of a particular proposition which is most relevant to the discourse topic and, on the part of the addressee, identification of a particular proposition which is sufficiently relevant to the discourse topic. On this view, several seemingly unrelated “puzzles” of the English present perfect amount to violations of a general pragmatic principle of optimal relevance, instead of independently motivated principles.