Abstract:Soil water evaporation plays a critical role in mass and energy exchanges across the land–atmosphere interface. Although much is known about this process, there is no agreement on the best modeling approaches to determine soil water evaporation due to the complexity of the numerical modeling scenarios and lack of experimental data available to validate such models. Existing studies show numerical and experimental discrepancies in the evaporation behavior and soil water distribution in soils at various scales, driving us to revisit the key process representation in subsurface soil. Therefore, the goal of this work is to test different mathematical formulations used to estimate evaporation from bare soils to critically evaluate the model formulations, assumptions and surface boundary conditions. This comparison required the development of three numerical models at the REV scale that vary in their complexity in characterizing water flow and evaporation, using the same modeling platform. The performance of the models was evaluated by comparing with experimental data generated from a soil tank/boundary layer wind tunnel experimental apparatus equipped with a sensor network to continuously monitor water–temperature–humidity variables. A series of experiments were performed in which the soil tank was packed with different soil types. Results demonstrate that the approaches vary in their ability to capture different stages of evaporation and no one approach can be deemed most appropriate for every scenario. When a proper top boundary condition and space discretization are defined, the Richards equation-based models (Richards model and Richards vapor model) can generally capture the evaporation behaviors across the entire range of soil saturations, comparing well with the experimental data. The simulation results of the non-equilibrium two-component two-phase model which considers vapor transport as an independent process generally agree well with the observations in terms of evaporation behavior and soil water dynamics. Certain differences in simulation results can be observed between equilibrium and non-equilibrium approaches. Comparisons of the models and the boundary layer formulations highlight the need to revisit key assumptions that influence evaporation behavior, highlighting the need to further understand water and vapor transport processes in soil to improve model accuracy.

Prediction of Changes in Soil Moisture Due to Rainfall, Infiltration, and Evapotranspiration Using a Physically-Based Model

Modeling Soil Moisture Responses under Evaporative Conditions

Simulation of Dynamic Root Growth and Water Transfer in Soil-Crop-atmosphere System

Extending the Integrated Richards Equation Method to New Boundary Conditions: Model Description and Validation

A Physically-Based Integrated Numerical Model for Flow, Upland Erosion, and Contaminant Transport in Surface-Subsurface Systems

Integrated Two-Dimensional Surface and Three-Dimensional Subsurface Contaminant Transport Model Considering Soil Erosion and Sorption

An Easily Implemented Agro-Hydrological Procedure with Dynamic Root Simulation for Water Transfer in the Crop–soil System: Validation and Application

Simulation of Soil Erosion and Sediment Transport Using a Physically-Based Integrated Surface-Subsurface Model

Coupled Finite-Volume Model for 2D Surface and 3D Subsurface Flows

Simulation of Rainfall-Runoff in the Deep Hollow Lake Watershed Using an Integrated Surface-Subsurface Flow Model

Numerical simulation of the evapotranspiration process in the soil-vegetation-atmosphere continuum

Soil moisture migration model based on flux-concentration relation under steady rainfall

A two-layer numerical model of soil moisture dynamics: Model development

Evaluation of Model Concepts to Describe Water Transport in Shallow Subsurface Soil and Across the Soil–Air Interface

A two-dimensional Richards equation solver based on CVODE for variably saturated soil water movement

Rainfall Manipulation Experiments As Simulated by Terrestrial Biosphere Models: Where Do We Stand?

Numerical Simulation of Evapotranspiration Mechanism over Soil - Vegetation - Atmosphere System

Development and Application of a Physically-Based Distributed Rainfall-Runoff Model

A modified model predicting the hydraulic properties of variably saturated soil accounting for film and capillary flow

Physically based hydrological model using finite volume methods based on a triangulated irregular network

Using Precipitation, Vertical Root Distribution, and Satellite‐retrieved Vegetation Information to Parameterize Water Stress in a Penman‐Monteith Approach to Evapotranspiration Modeling under Mediterranean Climate