Nat Brandt: Massacre in Shansi. xxiv, 336 pp. Syracuse, NY: Syracuse University Press, 1994. $29.95.
Robert A. Bickers
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/S0041977X00011423
1995-06-01
Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies
Abstract:'The man who became known both as the Butcher of Shansi and the Chinese Nero was not through yet by any means.' Nat Brandt's narrative of the fates of American Protestant missionaries in Shanxi province during the Boxer rising abounds with such declarations. This comment (p. 233) concerns Yuxian, Governor of Shanxi province in 1900, and responsible for ordering the grisly beheading of some 45 foreign missionaries and their dependents in Taiyuan in July that year (in, naturally, "The Courtyard of Slaughter', p. 223). The book focuses in great detail on the lives of a band of evangelists from Oberlin College, Ohio, who worked in China for the American Board of Commissioners for Foreign Missions. Their martyrdom is commemorated by an arch on the campus that is still today the subject of annual demonstrations and arguments. Brandt is a popular historian, with a reasonable sense of narrative structure, who has worked competently with the surviving archival relics of his missionaries, and with the secondary literature on the subject. Those records are viewed rather uncritically, however, despite the fact that many of the squabbles and problems of missionary life are discussed. He has less of a grip on the modern literature about the Boxer rising, and about the character and strength of Western imperialisms in China. The old paradigms are trotted out; civilizations collide and cultures clash and, as usual, one represents the past and the other the future. Brandt is not really concerned with these wider issues; the book is, in fact, a modern martyrology. In contrast to the post-Boxer volumes that gather dust on our library shelves (Steadfast unto death!, or Martyred missionaries of the China Inland Mission), it does give a great deal of space to the lives and deaths of Chinese mission workers and converts, but it is not their story. It concerns the fates that befell a small group of earnest and sincere American men and women in China in 1900 whose earnestness and sincerity were misunderstood by, among others, the Boxers. No new papers have been uncovered which might throw added light on the situation in Shanxi province, and explain the tensions there between Christian and non-Christian Chinese. The book is perhaps useful as a guide to the sources available, and in its description of the domestic lives and life histories of its subjects perhaps might be said to add a little something illustrative in the direction so already well-mapped out by Jane Hunter's The gospel of gentility (New Haven, [1984]). Except as a historiographical oddity, however, it holds no interest for the historian. There are other points. / Ho Chiian ('Boxers') is mistakenly substituted throughout for / Ho T 'uan; hui (£,) does not refer exclusively to 'secret societies' (p. 144); Brandt's claim that Sir Edmund Backhouse was responsible for the 'worst reports' about the behaviour and background of the Empress Dowager Cixi is quite curious (especially considering his account of her in the unpublished 'Memoirs'), and to describe Backhouse as 'given to hyperbole' (p. 136) is an outrageous understatement.
History