Abstract:Based on the significant differences between rice and wheat cultivation, Talhelm et al. (2014) divided the Chinese culture into two types, respectively: rice culture and wheat culture. The former is closer to East Asian culture, and the latter to Western culture. Although the “Rice Theory” provides a novel perspective, it remains to be tested before it’s established. For example, why is holistic-thinking prevalent in China? The “Rice Theory” argues that agricultural types result into cultural differences. Specifically, a long history of rice cultivation should make people live in the rice area more interdependent and thus prefer holistic-thinking, while that of wheat cultivation should make people live in the wheat area more individualistic and thus prefer analytical-thinking. Although the “Rice Theory” provides a new perspective in explaining the differences between rice culture and wheat culture and the prevalence of holistic-thinking in China, the real reason for Chinese, especially ancient Chinese, preferring holistic-thinking may not be a long history of rice cultivation. This paper focuses on explaining this new theory in details. (221-220 BC), were mostly from the northern wheat region. Overall, these two contradictions suggested that the “Rice Theory” was invalid. The external reasons for the prevalence of holistic-thinking in China is probably the enlightenments and inspirations derived from flood control practices, especially the contrast between Yu’s success and Gun’s failure in flood control, which made the Chinese ancients intuitively realized the importance of the harmony between man and nature, and thus considering beings comprehensively (the prototype of holistic-thinking) in solving complicated problems. And the internal reasons is probably the proposal and acceptance of the Yin-Yang theory which contains the thought of Yin-Yang, the Five Elements theory which contains the thought of Five Elements, and the combined Yin Yang-Five Elements theory which contains the thought of Yin-Yang and Five Elements. They provide a complete set of thinking methods to utilize the holistic-thinking for Chinese. Due to the logical and systematic explaining of the birth, growing, sickness and death of the universe, these theories were regarded the rule of thinking by ancient Chinese. They also promoted ancient Chinese to use the holistic, dynamic, and self-adaptive thinking model to explain manifold natural and social phenomena. To sum up, (1) the “Rice Theory” is invalid to explain preference of holistic thinking among Chinese, due to its lack of cultural and ecological validity. (2) It is the flood control practice together with the Yin-Yang thinking, Five Elements thinking, and combined Yin Yang-Five Elements theory that lead to the holistic thinking of ancients Chinese. Insofar, the habit of using holistic thinking to understand and solve problems by Chinese is indestructible.

Does Rice Farming Shape Individualism and Innovation?

People quasi-randomly assigned to farm rice are more collectivistic than people assigned to farm wheat

How Rice Farming Shaped Culture in Southern China

When R&D Spending Is Not Enough: The Critical Role Of Culture When You Really Want To Innovate

Genome-Wide Association Study of Eating and Cooking Qualities in Different Subpopulations of Rice (oryza Sativa L.)

The Role of Relational Orientation As Measured by Face and Renqing in Innovative Behavior in China: an Indigenous Analysis

Analysis of Evolutionary Relationships Provides New Clues to the Origins of Weedy Rice

The Lineage Theory of the Regional Variation of Individualism/Collectivism in China

How Rice Fights Pandemics: Nature–Crop–Human Interactions Shaped COVID-19 Outcomes

Questioning the Rice Theory: Also on the internal and external causes of Chinese preference for holistic thinking

Beyond cultural norms: how does historical rice farming affect modern firms' family control?

Is Small Still Beautiful? A Comparative Study of Rice Farm Size and Productivity in China and India

High-status People Are More Individualistic and Analytic-Thinking in the West and Wheat-Farming Areas, but Not Rice-Farming Areas

Integrated Phenotypic, Phylogenomic, and Evolutionary Analyses Indicate the Earlier Domestication of Geng Upland Rice in China

Hybrid Rice Innovation in China: A Study of Market Demand Induced Technological Innovation in a Centrally-Planned Economy

Relationship between rice farming and polygenic scores potentially linked to agriculture in China

Public Research Resource-Allocation in Chinese Agriculture - A Test of Induced Technological Innovation Hypotheses

Economic Effect on Crop Genetic Diversity

Assessing the Contribution of Research System and CG Genetic Materials to the Total Factor Productivity of Rice in China.

When Interdependence Backfires: The Coronavirus Infected Three Times More People in Rice-Farming Areas During Chinese New Year

Collectivism culture and green transition: An empirical investigation for the rice theory