Abstract:1. Whether fragmented ecosystems can maintain diversity is a key ecological question. The ability of fragmented forests to support diversity is determined by both landscape‐scale metapopulation dynamics and within‐patch mechanisms that govern species coexistence. Within‐patch dynamics can be affected by proximity to forest edges. Edge effects on abiotic and biotic processes can alter species' performance and species interactions, but it is unclear how edge effects bear upon the long‐term ability of fragmented forests to maintain diversity.2. We apply modern coexistence theory as a framework to predict the impact of edge effects on species coexistence. Using field data for a tropical tree community, we parameterized a spatially‐explicit simulation model to quantify how habitat and density‐dependence during seedling establishment affects diversity of later life‐stages. We matched simulated future communities to observed patterns of diversity and community structure for established seedlings and adults, coupled with sensitivity analysis of simulated effects.3. We found that early recruitment dynamics contributed to community structure at older life‐stages, corroborating empirical work on the importance of early life‐stage dynamics for diversity. Edge effects reduced the diversity maintained in patches. The progressive loss of diversity was not due to changes in relative competitive ability (fitness differences), but due to weaker stabilization via density‐dependent seed mortality. Results were robust to wide changes in the absolute values of model parameters, suggesting that variation in the strength of individual processes did not change their relative importance for diversity.4. Synthesis: Weakening of stabilizing processes that promote species self‐limitation in ecological communities could compromise the ability of fragment patches to maintain diversity. Quantifying the relative importance of intraspecific vs. interspecific interactions—to assess stabilizing mechanisms and fitness differences—in fragmented habitats, can help evaluate when habitat amount vs. quality plays a larger role in maintaining diversity of fragments.

Intermediate Fragmentation Per Se Provides Stable Predator-Prey Metapopulation Dynamics

Landscape fragmentation overturns classical metapopulation thinking

Assessing Habitat Fragmentation’s Hierarchical Effects on Species Diversity at Multiple Scales: the Case of Thousand Island Lake, China

Dispersal limitation and weaker stabilizing mechanisms mediate loss of diversity with edge effects in forest fragments

Robustness of Metacommunities with Omnivory to Habitat Destruction: Disentangling Patch Fragmentation from Patch Loss.

Habitat Fragmentation Affects Richness—A View Through a Metacommunity Lens

Decoupling Species Richness Variation and Spatial Turnover in Beta Diversity Across a Fragmented Landscape

Positive effects of fragmentation per se on the most iconic metapopulation

Spatial Pattern of Habitat Quality Modulates Population Persistence in Fragmented Landscapes

Geometric and demographic effects explain contrasting fragmentation-biodiversity relationships across scales

Metapopulation Capacity Determines Food Chain Length in Fragmented Landscapes.

Habitat Fragmentation Drives Plant Community Assembly Processes Across Life Stages.

Dispersal-enhanced resilience in two-patch metapopulations: origin's instability type matters

Metapopulation Dynamics Response to the Spatial Heterogeneity of Habitat Destruction

The Effects of Landscape Variables on the Species-Area Relationship During Late-Stage Habitat Fragmentation.

Species diversity and habitat fragmentation per se: The influence of local extinctions and species clustering

The effects of fragmentation per se on patch occupancy are stronger and more positive in a landscape with a higher quality and more homogeneous matrix

The influence of fragmented landscapes on speciation

Survivability of a metapopulation under local extinctions

Effect of Landscape Fragmentation on Plant Populations

Episodic population fragmentation and gene flow reveal a trade-off between heterozygosity and allelic richness