Comparison of liquefaction processes for small-scale LNG plants | Comparaison des procedes de GNL pour des installations petite echelle

Anzhong Gu,Wensheng Lin,Gang Zhu

2001-01-01

Abstract:The rapid growth of the economics in China and the preference for a cleaner energy source make the country a large potential LNG market. Considering the present market demand and the feasibility of technology, building small-scale LNG plants proved to be the most practical way to start LNG industry in China. Nowadays, a series of small-scale LNG plant is building to cope with peak loads and to increase the economy of gas fields. Due to huge investment of these LNG projects, investors are interested in reducing the capital cost and lowering operating cost. Since liquefaction units account for 35-40% of the total plant cost, a study was made to select the optimum liquefaction process to increase the economy of these small-scale LNG plants. A same basis was used to evaluate three types of liquefaction cycles, i.e., propane pre-cooling mixed refrigerant cycle (MRC), nitrogen-methane expander cycle, and two-stage MRC. Propane pre-cooling MRC was most efficient and the most complicated cycle. It could be used in base load plants and some of the large peak-shaving plants. The expander cycle was the most inefficient and simplest. It could be adopted in marginal gas field and some of the small peak-shaving plants. The two-stage MRC was much simpler than the propane pre-cooling MRC, while its power consumption was only a bit higher than the latter. It is suitable for most peak-shaving plants.