A note on Cauchy-Voigt dispute of independent constants in anisotropic elastic Hooke's law

D.X. Du,Q.-S. Zheng
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0093-6413(99)00027-0
IF: 2.749
1999-01-01
Mechanics Research Communications
Abstract:The theory with at most 21 independent elastic parameters, called multi-constant one, corresponds to the existence of a strain energy function date to Green, or equivalently, requires that the elastic modulus tensor Cijkl possesses the major index symmetry: Cijkl = Cjikl = Cijlk = Cklij. The theory with at most 15 independent elastic parameters, called rari-constant one, requires the following six constraints: c2233 = c2323, c3311 = c3131, c1122 = c1212, c1123 = c3112, c2231 = c1223, c3312 = c2331,which are called Cauchy's relations. The multi-constant theory was supported by Green, Stokes, Kirchhoff, and others, while the rari-constant one was agreed with by Poisson, Lord Kelvin, Lame, and others. In 1887, Voigt reported a set of decisive experimental results which most likely to be right.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?