The Attribution and Emotion Transformation of Fragile Self-esteem After Ego-threats

Pan Yizhong,Xu Yan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.16719/j.cnki.1671-6981.2011.01.028

IF: 10.172

2011-01-01

Psychological Science

Abstract:There are notable divarications on the causation of defensive incline of Fragile High Self-esteem between theorists' proposition and studies.Theorists propose that the defensive incline of Fragile High Self-esteem is rooted in the separation between explicit and implicit self-esteem and corresponding internal attribution after ego-threats.But most of studies have showed that those with fragile self-esteem show external attribution and hostility or aggression(see Sandstrom & Jordan,2007) except for few studies supporting the academic reasoning mentioned above(Harter,1993;Tangney,Wagner,& Gramzow,1992).We postulate that there is a transformation of attribution and emotion after ego-threats and most of former studies haven't differentiated among immediate attribution and accompanying emotion and re-attribution and accompanying emotion. To test the hypothesis mentioned above,the present study recruited 89 subjects who were all college students and carried out a 3 (grouping:immediate group;re-attribution group;unrelated task group)×3(self-esteem type:fragile self-esteem;secure self-esteem; low self-esteem) between-subjects experiment.Firstly we filtered the subjects of 3 self-esteem types based on their scores of explicit and implicit self-esteem.In the formal experiment,all of the 3 types of subjects accomplished an alleged short-term memory efficiency test and accepted a feedback.The feedback was always negative and indicated that the grade was inferior to that of most of college students.In the immediate group,the subjects were directed to evaluate how his/her current feeling was congruent with those emotion words selected from PANA-X which measure shame and hostility immediately after the feedback.In the re-attribution group, the subjects completed a brief questionair consisting of 4 items which measured the re-attribution level before an emotion measurement. In the unrelated task group,the subjects counted his/her own pulse before an emotion measurement. The results showed that the subjects of fragile self-esteem experienced stronger shame than those of secure self-esteem in the immediate condition,and exhibited an external attribution if given re-attribution opportunity and then transformed shame into hostility.As to low self-esteem,they experienced stronger shame than those of secure self-esteem the in immediate condition,too.But they didn't use external attribution in the re-attribution condition and the level of hostility didn't increase. The present study demonstrates that the transeformation of attribution and emotion after ego-threats does exist for fragile self-esteem. The second finding is that those of low self-esteem always keep internal attribution and corresponding shame after ego-threats. These findings are significant for the understanding of the relations between depression and self-esteem.The findings also suggest that we should pay attention to the difference between immediate attribution and accompanying emotion and re-attribution and accompanying emotion in future studies.In doing so,we can get more exact and intensive comprehension for fragile self-esteem and other self-esteem types.