From a Formalist Concept of Punishment to a Substantial Concept of Punishment——A Comment on M v. Germany Judgment of ECHR 2009

JIANG Su

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1672-769X.2012.04.012

2012-01-01

Abstract:The main controversy over M v. Germany of ECHR in 2009 is whether the security measure in German Penal Code is a punishment and whether this measure has a retrospective effect. On this issue, German Constitutional Court and German government adhere to a formalist concept of punishment and argue that the security measure in German Penal Code is merely a kind of security actions but not a kind of punishment. On the contrary, European Court of Human Rights argues that the security measure in German Penal Code is no less than a kind of punishment. Behind these two concepts lies in the conflict between nationalism and liberalism. From the perspective of substantial concept of punishment, it can be argued that reform-through-labor in China is not merely a kind of administrative measure, while it is a kind of punishment. Therefore, it should be included in the penal code.