Preliminary Study of Detection Accuracy of Single Pulmonary Nodules by Using Image Diagnostic Monitors with Same Resolution and Different Brand

郑彤,陈卫国,谢苏民,程勇,黄婵桃,廖昕,唐浩,罗振东
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-0313.2010.04.026
2010-01-01
Abstract:Objective:By use of image diagnostic monitors with different brand and same resolution to compare detection accuracy of pulmonary nodules on the chest digital radiography (DR) and to evaluate the brand diagnostic performance between the displays.Methods:From the picture archiving and communication system (PACS) the database were searched from March 2005-December 2008 of our hospital to find out patients with confirmed or suspicious lung nodules by chest DR for CT examination.Single nodule found by CT with diameter 30mm classified as the positive group and those with no nodules as the negative group.Five doctors used three brands of monitors with 5-grade method (definite,possible,uncertain,possibly not,certainly not) to judge independently whether there were nodules or not.ROC curves were drawn according to the reading results,areas under the curves and the diagnostic effectiveness of different brands were compared.Results:The average reading on 3 brands of displays in the 1~10mm group of solitary pulmonary nodules viewed by the 5 radiological doctors were Az (A)=0.877±0.053,Az (B)=0.895±0.050,Az (C)=0.887±0.051,respectively.Those in the 10~30mm group were Az (A)=0.891±0.045,Az (B)=0.901±0.044,Az (C)=0.892±0.045.Conclusion:Since the resolution of the three types of displays used was the same (3MP),it can be seen from the ROC curve that Az areas under the curve,though they are different,are all close the 0.9,indicating that the diagnosis efficiency of LCD of 3MP for solitary pulmonary nodules is high,in which the area of Brand B is the greatest.By stastistical testing,P values are different.It can be drawn that 3MP display images had statistically significant difference in the readings of pulmonary nodules,but there is no difference in the effectiveness of diagnosis.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?