Abstract:Recently, the number of regional trade agreements (RTAs) has flourished and at the same time, trade disputes are increasing. The dispute settlement mechanisms (DSMs) in those RTAs may be potentially at odds with the DSM of the World Trade Organization (WTO), the Understanding on Rules and Procedures Governing the Settlement of Disputes (DSU). The interaction between the DSMs of the WTO and in RTAs raise various concerns, including forum shopping and conflicts of jurisdiction. The key question is: which DSM should prevail? The relationship between the DSU and the default DSM in the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) provides an example of such an interaction and illustrates the potential fragmentation in case of overlapping jurisdiction. In the Mexico – Tax Measures on Soft Drinks and Other Beverages case, the WTO’s Appellate Body was reluctant to adopt a straightforward position on such overlaps. Thus, at least for now, there are many open questions, but no clear-cut answers. After providing an overview of the legal framework and discussing this important case, the authors propose solutions as to how to deal with jurisdictional overlaps in trade disputes. World Trade Organization (WTO), Understanding on Rules and Procedures Governing the Settlement of Disputes (DSU), Mexico – Soft Drinks, regional trade agreements (RTA), North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), dispute settlement mechanisms, jurisdiction, proliferation, multiplication, international courts and tribunals

On the Issues of Compensation in WTO Dispute Settlement Mechanism: from the Perspective of Developing Countries

Developing Members'Access to WTO Dispute Settlement:Dilemma and Capacity

Legal System of Compensation for Marine Oil Pollution in China

The Hierarchy of Remedies under the WTO Dispute Settlement System and Its Impact

A Positive Study of Dispute Settlements Involving China Since Its Accession to the WTO

How Does the WTO Dispute Settlement Mechanism Work for WTO Members? A Comparative Analysis of Developed and Developing Countries

The Sustainability of the WTO Dispute Settlement System: Does It Work for Developing Countries?

Limitations of WTO Disputes Settlement Mechanism in Domestic Implementation of TRIPS Agreement

From Confrontation To Coexistence: An Appeal Opt-Out Arrangement As An Inclusive Approach To Revive The WTO Dispute Settlement System?

On the Legal Enforceability of WTO S&D Treatment Provisions

Long-Term Relationship over Litigation: Mediation in WTO Dispute Settlement Proceedings

China'S Experience in Dealing with Wto Dispute Settlement: A Chinese Perspective

On Examination of Domestic Laws in the WTO Dispute of Settlement

Dispute Resolution Mechanisms and Organizations in the Implementation of 'one Belt, One Road' Initiative: Whence and Whither

China’s Path to the Center Stage of WTO Dispute Settlement: Challenges and Responses

Succinct Discussion On The Role's Transition of China In The Dispute Settlement Mechanism of WTO

On the Market Disruption and the Abuse of the Transitional Product-Specific Safeguard Measures Against China

On Administrative Litigation Of International Trade From Multiple Perspectives

The Effect of WTO DSM Reform on Dispute Settlement Result

Some Rational Thoughts on the Sino-US Steel Dispute

The WTO’s Exclusive and Compulsory Jurisdiction v.Dispute Resolution Mechanisms in Regional Trade Agreements: A Clash of Jurisdiction?