Abstract:Even in the case of an insured event, the insurer is exempted from liability for insurance payments if it falls under grounds for exemption clauses in insurance contract. Professor Edwin W. Patterson, a renowned American insurance law jurist, divided exemption clauses into ‘exception’ and ‘exclusion’. In Patterson’s view, ‘exception’ is excepted causes of insured event, and ‘exclusion’ is the event to be excluded from insured event. He asserted that the insurer is not liable for paying the insurance payments, because an event that falls under ‘exclusion’ is not an insured event. Patterson’s ‘exception/exclusion distinction’ influenced some Korean insurance law scholars for a long time. In Korea, scholars influenced by Professor Patterson argue that the exemption clauses are divided into ‘exception to liability’ and ‘exclusion to covered perils’. ‘Exception to liability’ is ‘exception’ from Patterson’s view and ‘exclusion to covered perils’ is ‘exclusion’. In the theory of the distinction between ‘exception to liability’ and ‘exclusion to covered perils’, like Patterson’s view, the insurer is not liable for the event that falls under the ‘exclusion to covered perils’ because it is not an insured event. Scholars who support the distinction theory argue that it is natural for the insurer not to pay the insurance payments because ‘exclusion to covered perils’ is not the covered perils of the insurance contract. Korean distinction theory take as an example the unlicensed driving exclusion, which is a exemption clause of auto liability insurance, and call this exemption as a ‘exclusion to covered perils’ that is excluded from insured event. However, an accident that occurred while driving without a license also falls under the insured event(“accident that occurred while the insured owns, uses, and manages the insured car”), under the policy of auto liability insurance. Like unlicensed driving exclusion, the ‘exclusion to covered perils’ is written so that the insurer is exempted regardless of the causal relationship. However, it is not reasonable to conclude that ‘exclusion to covered perils’ is not included in covered perils and is excluded from the scope of insured event just because it is written in a non-causal format. Therefore, same as ‘exceptions’(exception to liability), policy clauses classified as ‘exclusions’(exclusions to covered perils) are also should be subject to the control of the court. In addition, because Patterson and Korean distionction theory do not provide a clear criterion for distinction, the absolute power should not be given to the ‘exclusion’. The legal validity of the distinction theory is very questionable.

The Abandon of the Right to Claim for Damages Compensation and the Insurer's Subrogation Right——Concentrating on Japanese Case Analysis

On Payment of Insurance Compensation and Compensation for Damage

Disclosure in insurance law: a comparative analysis

Development Of Maritime Limitation Of Liability In China (1993-2011)

A Study of the Application of Subrogation to Casualty Insurance

From a Comparative Law Perspective to Study the Intentional Object of the Insurance Contract Deliberate Disclaimer

A Reflection on and Reconstruction of China's Insurance System of Insurer's Explanation Obligation:Comments on Article 17 of New Insurance Law

On Importance of the Differences between the Right of Subrogation and Indemnity

The Obligation of Insurance Payment in Single Vehicle Accident:Focusing on the Case That a Driver Killed by His Own Vehicle Parked

The Insurer’ s Bad Faith in Denial of Claims---from the Perspective of Tort of Bad Faith in American Insurance Law

Dilemma and Outlet: Judgement of Insurable Interest in Property Insurance Contract

Termination of Insurance Contract due to Violation of Obligation to Give Notice under Article 652 of the Commercial Law: A critical analysis of the Korea Supreme Court Case No. 2012Da62318 rendered on 24. July 2014

A Case Study of the Choice of the Right Compensator under CIF when the Buyer Finds Damages

Maritime Lien and Insurance Compensation

Think about Exemption of Liabilities of Nautical Fault Again

On the Principle of Indemnity in Medical Expense Insurance——The Interpretation and Application of Article No.46 of the Newly-issued Insurance Law

The Disproportionate Rights and Duties of the Insurer and the Insured in Fiji

The Concurrence of Tort Damages and Social Insurance Payments:Dilemma and Solutions

A Study on the Exemption Clauses in Insurance Contract: Focusing on the Theory of Distinction between ‘Exception to Liability’ and ‘Exclusion to Covered Perils’

The revised Insurance Law and the perfection of the legal system for marine cargo insurance contract in China

Socialization of Tort Law——Focus on the Relationship between Tort Law and Insurance