Socialization of Tort Law——Focus on the Relationship between Tort Law and Insurance
Liu Kaixiang,Zeng Yanfei
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.2095-3275.2013.01.003
2013-01-01
Abstract:The modern tort law principle,which provides compensation with priority,has changed the character of tort law,making the latter switch its emphasis from personal liability to loss spreading.The tort law,on the one hand,expands itself to strict liability and is influenced by the insurance ideology,on the other hand,the tort law,whose construction must base on the bilateral structure of plaintiff-defendant relationship,still faces such criticism as huge administrative cost,uncertainty and interpersonal unfairness.What's more,its expansion has caused the crisis in the liability insurance market.Confronting the tort law crisis,the moralists have in the few decades made efforts to again justify tort law with theories of corrective justice and social contract.The functionalists also point out that tort law owns the irreplaceable position in loss-prevention.Moreover,it's the essence of the insurance system that limits the scope of its function,as a result,only part of the damages would be compensated.In conclusion,tort law cannot be replaced by insurance system,but there is also neither positivistic nor theoretical justification for the hyper expansion of tort law as today we have.