A Reflection on and Reconstruction of China's Insurance System of Insurer's Explanation Obligation:Comments on Article 17 of New Insurance Law

Wu Yongmin,Hu Bin
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3785/j.issn.1008-942X.2010.01.191
2010-01-01
Abstract:In the course of practice,China's Insurance System of Insurer's Explanation Obligation is frequently abused by the insured,who tends to take it as a universally applicable tool when defending himself/herself against the insurer for interest. However,the range of this legal system is only restricted to insurance clauses,and its jurisprudence basis should be the restrictive principle of contract law for standard form contract. In this paper,the reconstruction of China's Insurance System of Insurer's Explanation Obligation is proposed. The basic ideas of the proposal include the following points: the explanation targets should be "clauses of rights and obligations"and "clauses of quasi rights and obligations"rather than "legal exemption clauses"; the explanation method in principle ought to be "oral and written",with "hold harmless clauses"as an exception; the explanation criterion should be "the understanding of an ordinary reasonable person" on an active explanation basis,and "the understanding of the insured" on a passive explanation basis; and the legal consequence should "not be laid into the insurance contract". Therefore,it seems that Article 17 of the new Insurance Law still needs the following amendments: "legal exemption articles" should be excluded in the explanation target; the legal regulation of "passive explanation" should be included in the explanation method; and the rule of "disintegration of contract" should be adopted when the legal consequence is taken into consideration.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?