Bureaucrats as Managers - Evidence from China

Joseph P. H. Fan,Jun Huang,Felix Oberholzer-Gee,Mengxin Zhao

2009-01-01

Abstract:Former civil servants lead a large number of companies in both developed and emerging economies. In this paper, we ask whether these managers make effective chief executives. To study this question, we examine strategic choices and the financial performance of publicly listed companies in China during the 2001 to 2005 period. Our results indicate that the bureaucratic past of CEOs has a profound influence on company strategy and financial returns. Former civil servants are more likely than other corporate leaders to enter new industries, and those who manage state-owned enterprises (SOEs) diversify their firms in a manner that is largely inconsistent with the recommendations of scholars of corporate strategy. As a result, the performance effects of diversification differ sharply across SOEs and private firms. More generally, we find little evidence that shareholders benefit from appointing former bureaucrats to the position of CEO despite their extensive knowledge of government processes in an economy where the influence of the state is all pervasive. Our findings add to the recent literature on the importance of managerial style and CEO characteristics. In our study CEOs matter, but we also show that private-sector incentives can largely mute the influence of personality. Specifically, former bureaucrats who manage private companies show few of the weaknesses that are characteristic of their peers at state-owned enterprises. In the context of private firms operating in China, private-sector incentives trump managerial style.