Applicability of the Plume Models for the Zone Modeling of the Smoke in Compartment Fires

陈长坤,姚斌
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3321/j.issn:1006-8740.2008.04.002
2008-01-01
Abstract:With different plume and spill plume correlations,a simple model was built to describe compartment fires.The zone method was used to calculate the temperature and thickness of hot smoke in compartment fires.The corresponding experiments were performed with the ISO 9705 full-scale standard fire experimental system.The applicability of the different plume models was analyzed on the basis of the comparison between the calculated results and the experimental data.The results demonstrated that the Thomas model and McCaffrey model predicted a greater plume flow,which caused a lower calculated smoke temperature,so they are inapplicable to large power fires.The plume flow predicted by the Zukoski model was smaller,and the calculated temperature was higher than the measured one,so it is more applicable to small power fires.The plume flow predicted by the Heskestad model was steady,and the result of the zone simulation agreed well with the experimental data,so it could be used to predict large power fires.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?