Comparion Between Transcatheter and Surgical Closure of Secondum Atrial Septal Defect over 50 Years of Age

关韶峰,潘欣,崔克俭,张卫,吴卫华,方唯一
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1004-8812.2005.06.005
2005-01-01
Abstract:Objective To compare the safety and recent efficacy between transcatheter and surgical closure of secondum atrial septal defect over 50 years of age. Methods Retrospective analysis was done on 66 patients over 50 years of age who underwent transcatheter (30 cases) and surgical (36 cases) closure of secondum atrial septal defect.The median age was 60.8±7.1 years old in the transcatheter closure group and (57.5±6.3) years old in the surgical closure group( P=0.04).The median sizes of atrial septal defect in the transcatheter and the surgical closure group were 24.9±7.2 mm and 30.4±11.0 mm respectively (P=0.02). We compared the recent efficacy、 complications and prognosis between two groups. Results The instant procedural success rate was 93.3% for the transcatheter closure group and 100% for the surgical group (P=0.85). 2 procedures in the transcatheter closure group failed, 1 patient (2.6%) in the surgical group died during hospitalization and 9 patients (25.0%) underwent Devage tricuspid annuloplasty. Newly onset atrial arrhythmias occurred in 3.3% in the transcatheter closure group and 22.2% in the surgical closure group (P=0.03). After the procedures, right atrial and ventricular dimensions were decreased from 38.0±9.0 mm to 35.2±10.1 mm and from 44.2±8.6 mm to 36.2±9.0 mm in the transcatheter closure group whereas in the surgial group, the atrial and ventricular sizes fell from 44.1±8.2 mm to 38.2±9.5 mm and 49.0±10.2 mm to 37.1±11.0 mm respectively (P0.01). The estimated pulmonary artery systolic pressure was decreased from 47.1±17.1 mm?Hg(1 mm?Hg=0.133 kPa) and 55.3±14.6 mm?Hg to 39.2±14.1 mm?Hg and 46.3±12.9 mm?Hg in the transcatheter closure group and the surgical closure group respectively (P0.01). There were no statistical difference in the above parameters between the 2 groups (P=0.55, 0.49, 0.22). Conclusion Both transcatheter and surgical treatment of atrial septal defect in patients over 50 years of age are safe and can improve right ventricular function. Surgical closure can be done independent of the anatomy of atrial septal defect,so its indication is more extensive despite its new atrial arrhythmia onset rate after the procedure is higher than that of transcatheter closure. In selected cases, transcatheter closure may have priorty over surgery.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?