On the Normative Intention of Defamation, the Right of Supervision and the 41st Clause of the Constitution

Shi Bifan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.14167/j.zjss.2013.04.016
2013-01-01
Abstract:Protecting the right of supervision is one of valuable objectives of the construction of democracy and the rule of law in China. "Defaming officials cases" revealed the conflicts between the right of supervision in the 41st clause of the Constitution and the prosecution procedure of defamation in the 246th clause of the criminal law. Only defamation is not to be prosecuted, and introducing "actual malice" principle in a private prosecution or reputation tort lawsuit, the right of supervision can be protected effectively, and the balance between the right of reputation of officials and the right of supervision can be fulfilled. Supervision by public opinion is a case of public interest and development of democratic politics, and should become the justifications for the defendants.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?