Disenchantment and Self- Satisfaction: Influence of Political Theories on Constitutional Interpretation and Its Limits

Xiang ZHANG

2007-01-01

Abstract:The essence of the constitutional jurisprudence is the jurisprudence of constitutional interpretation to conduct interpretation of the text of constitution for its application.However,because of the uncertainty of the text of the constitution,it is inevitable to bring political consideration into the constitutional interpretation.For the same constitutional provision,there might be different interpretations under different guidance of political theories.Examination of the influence of political theories on constitutional interpretation is a kind of disenchantment by social science of the logic self-satisfaction of jurisprudence,and it is valuable.However,selection of political theory randomly as the background of constitutional interpretation will lead to arbitrary interpretation and harm the value of invariability of law.Therefore,it should be rooted in the native constitutional history,the environment of the norm as well as the constitutional text to accommodate this kind of external of political theory argumentation so as to eliminate the harm to the definiteness of constitutional interpretation.