Dýnamis, the Babylonians, and Theaetetus 147C7–148d7

J HOYRUP
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/0315-0860(90)90001-t
IF: 0.306
1990-01-01
Historia Mathematica
Abstract:Traditionally, the Greek mathematical term dýnamis is interpreted alternately as “square” and “root/side of square.” A survey of the usages of the term and of the related verb dýnasthai by Plato, Aristotle, and various mathematical authors including Eudemos/Hippocrates, Euclid, Archimedes, Hero, Diophantos, and Nicomachos shows that all are compatible with a familiar concept of Babylonian mathematics, the square identified by (and hence with) its side. It turns out that a “geometers' dýnamis” and a “calculators' dýnamis” must be differentiated; that the technical usage for the former became fixed only around the mid-fourth century B.C.; and that it vanished except in specific connections and formulaic expressions by the third century. Along with the conceptual congruity, the Babylonian and Greek terms share a number of everyday connotations. This suggests that the Greek concept may have been inspired or borrowed from the Near East. This hypothesis can be neither proved nor disproved directly by the sources, but it is internally coherent and fruitful with regard to the existing material.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?